What is the final V in the vertical direction?

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
Lapse
Messages
49
Reaction score
4

Homework Statement


Screenshot of an online physics homework grader showing part (c) asking for the vertical velocity component vy just before the ball hits the ground, with a calculator keypad, hints, feedback and a submission history table of four attempts.


Homework Equations


Vy2 = Vyo2 + 2ayt
y = 1/2(Vyo + Vy)t

The Attempt at a Solution


So I have "solved" this problem with both the equations above.

Using the Vy2 equation I get the result of 32.83m/s.
Using the other equation I get a result of zero, because Δy = (0 - 55) = -55. However, if I consider that 55m a positive value, then I get 32.83m/s... same as first equation.

I knew Vyo = 0m/s because the initial velocity would only be in the x-direction since the ball "is thrown horizontally". To prove it I did the equation Δy = Vyot + 1/2ayt and got a result of 0m/s.

So, where am I going wrong?

I actually have a much bigger problem than just this one I'm posting. For some reason I cannot wrap my head around physics problems. I can do calculus, logic classes, philosophy, etc, but for some reason cannot make my mind look at physic's problems in the right way. Conceptually, all of these kinematic questions seem easy, but I am spending WAY more time on these problems than should be necessary. If you have an answer for this conundrum I welcome your responses...
 
Attachments
  • Screenshot of an online physics homework grader showing part (c) asking for the vertical velocity component vy just before the ball hits the ground, with a calculator keypad, hints, feedback and a submission history table of four attempts.
    upload_2019-2-13_21-47-2.png
    48.1 KB · Views: 778
Screenshot of an online physics homework problem 9 worth 10%: a ball thrown horizontally from a 55 m building lands 140 m away, with parts (a) time in air t = 3.35 s marked correct and (b) initial horizontal velocity v0x = 41.79 m/s marked correct.
 
Attachments
  • Screenshot of an online physics homework problem 9 worth 10%: a ball thrown horizontally from a 55 m building lands 140 m away, with parts (a) time in air t = 3.35 s marked correct and (b) initial horizontal velocity v0x = 41.79 m/s marked correct.
    upload_2019-2-13_21-56-28.png
    14.8 KB · Views: 491
I don't understand how you get ##V_y=0## using the second equation.

Isnt it ##-55=\frac{1}{2}(0+V_y)3.35\Rightarrow V_y=\frac{-2\cdot55}{3.35}=-32.83##?
 
Lapse said:

Homework Statement


[ ATTACH=full]238714[/ATTACH]

Homework Equations


Vy2 = Vyo2 + 2ayt
y = 1/2(Vyo + Vy)t

The Attempt at a Solution


So I have "solved" this problem with both the equations above.

Using the Vy2 equation I get the result of 32.83m/s.
Using the other equation I get a result of zero, because Δy = (0 - 55) = -55. However, if I consider that 55m a positive value, then I get 32.83m/s... same as first equation.

I knew Vyo = 0m/s because the initial velocity would only be in the x-direction since the ball "is thrown horizontally". To prove it I did the equation Δy = Vyot + 1/2ayt and got a result of 0m/s.

So, where am I going wrong?

I actually have a much bigger problem than just this one I'm posting. For some reason I cannot wrap my head around physics problems. I can do calculus, logic classes, philosophy, etc, but for some reason cannot make my mind look at physic's problems in the right way. Conceptually, all of these kinematic questions seem easy, but I am spending WAY more time on these problems than should be necessary. If you have an answer for this conundrum I welcome your responses...
You have an error in the first equation you list
Vy2 = Vyo2 + 2ayt​

You should have Δy rather than t , so it should be:
Vy2 = Vyo2 + 2ay(Δy) ,​
which is probably what you actually used if you got 32.83m/s for Vy.

Notice that when you solve an equation such as ##v_y^2 = 2(-9.8)(-55)## by taking the square root of both sides, the answer is:
##v_y = \pm \sqrt{1078} \approx \pm 32.83 ~. ##​

You then need to choose the sign consistent with the situation