Having a problem in steps while solving integrals

In summary, the conversation discusses a doubt in understanding the steps involved in integrating a function with differentiation inside, specifically in the context of kinematic equations. The expert summarizes that the manipulations and steps used in physics may seem incorrect mathematically, but they work because functions in physics are generally well-behaved. The expert also points out the importance of understanding the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus in order to properly grasp integration.
  • #1
prakhargupta3301
58
1

Homework Statement


My problem is in integral calculus (I'm new to it).
I know what it is and how it works (basically. I'm not too advanced right now).
The problem is as following: (I will be posting comments/reasons along with what I've done and with what logic/understanding I've done it. Please correct me if I'm wrong.)
I was trying to derive kinematic equations using differentiation.
a=d(v)/dt -{1. here, we differentiated velocity w.r.t time}
∫adt= ∫d(v) -{2. here, we have multiplied both sides by dt. I don't know how that's even possible but my teacher told it that way. If there is some other underlying logic, please be kind enough to enlighten me.}
at|vu= v -{3. a is taken as a constant. So, it comes out of the integration as it is. Integral of dv is v( how? I don't know. My teacher told it this way. (He explained it this way: Sum of multiple small dv's will be v. I got it during the class, but now I have a doubt. With respect to what are integrating dv?)
at=v-u
Derived.

Homework Equations


x_x_x

The Attempt at a Solution


This isn't a problem but a doubt in my understanding. So there are no attempts. I have already written what all there is.
Please help.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Those are standard steps so there isn't a lot to say except that's the way integration works. I would, however, do it differently. Starting with

##a = \frac{dv}{dt}##

I would integrate that equation with respect to ##t##.

##\int_{t_0}^{t_1} a dt = \int_{t_0}^{t_1} \frac{dv}{dt} dt##

Now, remembering that the integral is an anti derivative, we have

##\int_{t_0}^{t_1} a dt = v(t_1) - v(t_0)##

And, if ##a## is a constant, we have:

##a(t_1 - t_0) = v(t_1) - v (t_0)##
 
  • Like
Likes prakhargupta3301
  • #3
Hi,

Perhaps it helps you if you rephrase the ##d## in ##dt## by

" ##\Delta## with the understanding that we take the limit ##\Delta \downarrow 0## "

that way you 'see' that ## a \,dt = dv ## and all of those manipulations that physicists do without much consideration. For mathematicians it can be a horror to look at them, but in physics functions are generally well-behaved enough to talk like this.
 
  • Like
Likes prakhargupta3301
  • #4
PeroK said:
I would integrate that equation with respect to ttt.

∫t1t0adt=∫t1t0dvdtdt∫t0t1adt=∫t0t1dvdtdt\int_{t_0}^{t_1} a dt = \int_{t_0}^{t_1} \frac{dv}{dt} dt

Now, remembering that the integral is an anti derivative, we have

∫t1t0adt=v(t1)−v(t0)∫t0t1adt=v(t1)−v(t0)\int_{t_0}^{t_1} a dt = v(t_1) - v(t_0)
So, if there is a differentiation inside an integral, then what happens? I don't get how you just take it (v) out. (I understand differentiation is just opposite of integration, but I'm new to one being inside the other. Can you break it a bit more please?)
(I don't get what is wrong with the reply mech. Please don't mind the raw code for the equation. I don't know how this works so please forgive me)
Thank you.
 
  • #5
prakhargupta3301 said:
So, if there is a differentiation inside an integral, then what happens? I don't get how you just take it (v) out. (I understand differentiation is just opposite of integration, but I'm new to one being inside the other. Can you break it a bit more please?)
(I don't get what is wrong with the reply mech. Please don't mind the raw code for the equation. I don't know how this works so please forgive me)
Thank you.
That the integral of the derivative of a function is the function is the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus.

You need to know that before you can move on with integration.
 
  • Like
Likes prakhargupta3301
  • #6
BvU said:
Hi,

Perhaps it helps you if you rephrase the ##d## in ##dt## by

" ##\Delta## with the understanding that we take the limit ##\Delta \downarrow 0## "

that way you 'see' that ## a \,dt = dv ## and all of those manipulations that physicists do without much consideration. For mathematicians it can be a horror to look at them, but in physics functions are generally well-behaved enough to talk like this.

So, you're trying to say that mathematically, this is wrong, but in physics such manipulations work so I needn't worry?
Also, Just to be sure, what you wrote in the double quotation marks means: Change where we take the lowest limit to be nearly equal to 0?
Thank you.
 
  • #7
PeroK said:
That the integral of the derivative of a function is the function is the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus.

You need to know that before you can move on with integration.
Ok. I think I get it now. (Perhaps I'm getting these many silly doubts is because we aren't being taught calculus in totality but bits and pieces of it in Mathematical Tools section of physics class.)
Also, earlier I was thinking of v as a constant (I know that was ignorant of me) but I now realize it's a function!
Anyways, I checked it and now I know the Fundamental theorem of Calculus. Thanks to you!
 
  • Like
Likes PeroK

FAQ: Having a problem in steps while solving integrals

1. What are the common challenges when solving integrals?

Some common challenges when solving integrals include difficulty in identifying the correct integration technique, dealing with complex functions or limits, and making algebraic or arithmetic errors.

2. How can I improve my problem-solving skills in integration?

Improving problem-solving skills in integration can be achieved through practice, understanding the basic rules and techniques, and breaking down the problem into smaller, manageable steps.

3. What is the importance of checking my solution when solving integrals?

It is crucial to check your solution when solving integrals to ensure that there are no errors or mistakes made during the process. It also helps in building confidence and understanding the concepts better.

4. What should I do if I get stuck while solving an integral?

If you get stuck while solving an integral, take a step back and review the basic rules and techniques. You can also seek help from a tutor or consult with your peers to get a different perspective.

5. How can I recognize which integration technique to use for a given problem?

Recognizing which integration technique to use for a given problem requires practice and understanding of the different techniques such as substitution, integration by parts, trigonometric substitution, and partial fractions. It also involves analyzing the function and its limits to determine the most suitable technique.

Back
Top