Can binders improve SSP fertilizer granule hardness and storage characteristics?

  • Thread starter Thread starter rommie
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the potential use of binding agents to enhance the hardness and storage characteristics of SSP fertilizer granules. Participants explore various materials, their application methods, and the implications of their use in the granulation process.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Rommie, a junior engineer, is considering sodium silicate, potassium silicate, lignosulfonates, and bentonite clay as binding agents but is concerned about the effects on water solubility and drying times.
  • One participant suggests that bentonite can be added as a slurry and may become hydrophobic with a surfactant, but advises caution with silicates due to potential insolubility of micronutrients.
  • Rommie notes that the plant manager indicated bentonite cannot be added in slurry form, speculating that it might neutralize the acid in the slurry and affect reactions.
  • Another participant discusses the risks of plugging in reactors when using clay and suggests that a dilute clay slurry might be feasible if properly managed with surfactants.
  • There is a suggestion that bentonite could be suspended in drying air to coat prills, although this might lead to operational challenges.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the feasibility and implications of using various binding agents, particularly bentonite and silicates. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best approach and the specific effects of each binding agent.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention concerns about the interactions of binding agents with the fertilizer components and the potential for operational issues, such as plugging in reactors and drying challenges. There are also uncertainties regarding the effectiveness of different application methods.

rommie
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Dear Forum

I am a junior engineer newly appointed by a fertilizer production company. I have been given the assignment to improve the SSP granule hardness and storage characteristics. Currently the granules are too soft and the drying time prior to bagging is also long. I am considering adding a binding agent to the fertilizer. I have considered sodium silicate, potassium silicate, lignosulfonates or bentonite clay as possible agents. However I am having considerable trouble finding reliable information regarding the use of these agents and the application methods. For example I am worried that if I should use sodium silicate, the granules' water solubility would be lowered considerably after drying in the drier. The fertilizer powder is granulated using drum granulators and water. Any advice or information is sincerely appreciated.

Regards
Rommie
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
I am sure you will find literature from bentonite producers, and it can be added as a slurry to bind or act as a final coat. It should also become somewhat hydrophobic if a small amount of biodegradable surfactant is used in formulating. Look in patent literature with appropriate boolean search terms.

I would steer clear of silicates as they could render any micronutrients as insoluble rock. Also silicates can be hard to dry compared to clays.
 
Hi

Thank you for the advice!I have started to research bentonite clay. According to the plant manager it cannot be added in slurry form, he didn't explain why though, I'm assuming the clay might neutralize the acid in the slurry and influence the reactions. I am not sure whether adding it in a powder form to the powdered fertilizer and then granulating it using water would have any notable increases in granule strength. I am still searching for information and will post as soon as I have something that may be of interest.

Regards
Rommie
 
I can understand if the reactor is a tube or other reactor than a tank; plugging with clay would be very bad indeed... I thought however, that the fertilizer xtal slurry might be able to withstand the introduction of a clay slurry that is very dilute and held suspended with surfactant. The lines that feed the slurry would always have to be moving or plugging would be a problem due to the thixotropic effects of bentonite slurries.

If you are using a spray drier, the bentonite could be suspended in the drying air and may coat the prills and produce some of the results- I suspect it will also cause a lot of extra downtime chipping away coated walls... !>)