Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the potential synthesis of gold oxalate through the reaction of oxalic acid with gold (III) chloride. Participants explore the feasibility of this reaction, its implications, and alternative approaches for experimental applications, particularly in the context of petrology and carbon sources in high-temperature experiments.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Experimental/applied
Main Points Raised
- One participant inquires about the possibility of forming gold oxalate by combining aqueous solutions of oxalic acid and gold (III) chloride, noting a lack of literature on the subject.
- Another participant expresses doubt about the reaction's success, citing evidence that oxalate may reduce Au(III) and suggesting that AuCl3 exists primarily as a tetrachloroaurate anion in solution.
- Concerns are raised regarding the high cost of gold reagents and the limited known applications of gold oxalate, prompting suggestions for alternative, less expensive compounds.
- One participant mentions the potential explosive decomposition of silver oxalate when heated, speculating that gold oxalate might exhibit similar sensitivity.
- A participant with a background in experimental petrology explains their interest in gold oxalate as a carbon source in experiments involving molten silicate materials, emphasizing the need to avoid alkali-bearing materials.
- Suggestions for alternative carbon sources, such as calcium salts and formic acid, are proposed, with discussions on their potential effects on the redox state of the samples being studied.
- Concerns are raised about the reducing properties of formic acid, similar to oxalic acid, and the need for a CO2 source that does not alter the redox state of the sample.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express differing opinions on the feasibility of synthesizing gold oxalate and its potential applications. There is no consensus on the effectiveness of the proposed reaction or the suitability of alternative carbon sources.
Contextual Notes
Participants highlight limitations related to the availability of literature on gold oxalate synthesis, the high cost of gold reagents, and the potential impact of various carbon sources on the redox state of experimental samples.