Can someone check if this forces problem on an incline

4 replies · 1K views · last reply
Blockade
Messages
68
Reaction score
0
To me the force P that pulls the bottom block up the incline seems a little low. Can someone confirm with my setup and work in brown is correct? Thank you.

Problem:
Handwritten-annotated photo of a textbook problem: an incline plane with block A on top of plank B, pulley and force P, with handwritten sum-of-forces equations in x and y for both blocks.


Work:
Handwritten student work on an incline problem: free-body force equations for block A and block B (Sum Fy, Sum Fx, Sum Fy), a derivation of P = [mu_k mg - mg sin theta] + ..., and boxed result P = 2 mu_k mg, with a diagram of two stacked blocks on a sloped surface labelled P, T, mg and angle theta.
 
Would you expect P to be independent of ##\theta## ?
Draw a free body diagram for each of the blocks separately.
And I see one of the two blue arrows (the most illegible one :smile:) can't be right.
 
BvU said:
Would you expect P to be independent of ##\theta## ?
Draw a free body diagram for each of the blocks separately.
And I see one of the two blue arrows (the most illegible one :smile:) can't be right.

ΣFxA : P - T - (3mgsinθ) - μk mgcosθ= 0

That was your hint right XD.
 
Blockade said:
ΣFxA : P - T - (3mgsinθ) - μk mgcosθ= 0

That was your hint right XD.
How about clearly stating what forces act on the plank and what forces act on the block - separately.

The mass of the block is 2m, right. Why do you have 3m ?

The plank acts on the block via friction and via the tension in the cord.
 
4
SammyS said:
How about clearly stating what forces act on the plank and what forces act on the block - separately.

The mass of the block is 2m, right. Why do you have 3m ?

The plank acts on the block via friction and via the tension in the cord.

I will redo the problem and post it back up. Thanks for you input.