Can You Stand an Egg Perfectly on Its Long End with Just Fevicol?

  • Thread starter Thread starter T@P
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Egg
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers around the myth of balancing an egg on its long end, particularly during the equinox. Participants assert that hard-boiling the egg or slightly crushing one end allows it to stand upright. The conversation references the historical anecdote of Filippo Brunelleschi, who demonstrated this principle by breaking the egg's end to balance it. Additionally, the use of salt as a stabilizing agent is suggested as a practical method for achieving this feat.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of egg structure and density
  • Basic knowledge of physics related to balance and gravity
  • Familiarity with the concept of equinoxes
  • Awareness of historical anecdotes in science
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the physics of balance and stability in objects
  • Explore the historical context of Filippo Brunelleschi's architectural achievements
  • Investigate the scientific validity of myths surrounding the equinox
  • Learn about practical applications of using salt for stabilization in various contexts
USEFUL FOR

Anyone interested in physics, science enthusiasts, educators looking for engaging demonstrations, and individuals curious about historical anecdotes in science.

T@P
Messages
274
Reaction score
0
how do you stand an egg perfectly on its long end on a totally smooth surface? you can't use anything but the egg you use to stand on end. JUST THE EGG.

and its supposed to stand on end. and its easy and repeatable. its not a "try for 6 years" kind of thing.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Answer: Don't you hard boil it while it is standing on its end, or something like that? I believe the yolk is denser, and will act as ballast.
 
If you are talking about a raw egg... I am pritty sure it is done on a solstest, winter or summer. Its suposidly the only time it can be done. I have on the other hand been told people have succeded in doing it at other times.


Of course if you are talking about a hard boiled egg all you need do is squish the end a bit and it will stand just fine! I have personally tested that theory. :biggrin:
 
xjuggleboy, you got it!

its more of a joke than a puzzle, sorry to those that got all excited. and yes, hard-boiled
 
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW! :frown:
 
even if it's raw egg, just crash the end and it will stnd up straight ^^
 
WOO! My first correct answer in the Brainteasers Forum! ::biggrin::
 
btw this is a fun trick to make people go away from you: just pull out an egg and suddenly everyone gets bored of you and leaves thinking you are the nerdiest person alive.

;)
 
I should try it...
 
  • #10
xJuggleboy said:
If you are talking about a raw egg... I am pritty sure it is done on a solstest, winter or summer. Its suposidly the only time it can be done. I have on the other hand been told people have succeded in doing it at other times.
This is a total myth, BTW.
 
  • #11
DaveC426913 said:
This is a total myth, BTW.

I didnt say it was true... I just said I have heard of people doing it.
 
  • #12
DaveC426913 said:
xJuggleboy said:
If you are talking about a raw egg... I am pritty sure it is done on a solstest, winter or summer. Its suposidly the only time it can be done. I have on the other hand been told people have succeded in doing it at other times.
This is a total myth, BTW.
No it's not, I've stood eggs up on the sidewalk during sostest, it's not a myth at all, maybe you've just tried it at the wrong time or something.
 
  • #13
need a title ?

wasteofo2 said:
No it's not, I've stood eggs up on the sidewalk during sostest, it's not a myth at all, maybe you've just tried it at the wrong time or something.

if it's not a myth or sumtin, can u explain why it is possible durint sostest while the other time not (scientifically, not kind of, god of Earth is a bit nice that day)
 
  • #14
well see the Earth god is a cool guy. :)

actually i think the reason is that people try doing it on solstet or something and if a lot of ppl try it that day, some succeed. or something.
 
  • #15
ooo, kind of strange answer actually but still make sense. a lot of people doing it so that the number of success increase or other sugesti ...
 
  • #16
A good way to cheat is to put a few grains of salt on a smooth surface and balance the egg on those. It's much easier with the salt crystals acting as 'props'. Once the egg is balanced, you can blow the remaining salt away and no one will notice the two or three remaining grains when you pick the egg up.
 
  • #17
Actually there is a story involving Filippo Brunelleschi, an italian architect during the renaissance which pertains to this. Regarding the building of the cupola of the duomo in florence, the other architects were jealous that he would not share his plans or collaborate with them, they believed that he could not build it. They pestered him saying he could not build it so he gave them a challenge make a boiled egg stand perfectly straight on its long end. They tried and fiddled with the egg but they could not do it. Then Brunelleschi takes the egg and smacks it on the table so the bottom gets broken and it can stay upright. The other architects protest saying they could have done that. His response is, "but you didn't that is why I'm building the duomo". That is the gist of how i heard the story, it's not exactly like that, but I believe that it's the right architect. I saw it in a documentary on the renaissance, although, that doesn't make it true. This discussion reminded me of that, thought i'd share.
 
  • #18
i have an answer in any season any weather
smash the egg on the ground so taht the one end is now flat and it will stand up
 
  • #19
Here is the answer to if the egg can balance on the equinox or not. This page is a good one if you have questions whether all those e-mails you get are true or not too.

http://www.snopes.com/science/equinox.htm
 
  • #20
??

?\\\\\
 
  • #21
Bad Astronomy (an excellent page in general) also has some info on this. Really, as mentioned on the page, it's usually enough for most people to try to balance eggs during the Equinox as well as any other time - most will instantly recognize that it's no harder or easier during any particular time. There could be a degree of "feeling" it as easier during the Equinox if sufficiently convinced, after all it's reather subjective and thus prone to interpretation one way or another (if one wishes it to be equally easy it may seem so and vice versa). Of course, gravity measurements much more precise then balancing an egg has shown that there *should* be no difference, but if eggs are (falsely IMO) assumed to have special properties it would really require a blind test with a statistically significant population who were unaware of either the legend or the current date to tell for double platinum sure. None have been done by either side afaik (though plenty of people do the much simpler comparison by "non-blind" balancing), but as insane as the original myth seems (yes, I've tried it both during the spring Equinox and during other times just to be generous and thus don't even have the tiny tiny doubts I may have had) I'd assume the people who do believe the myth would carry the burden of proof on this.
 
  • #22
just put the fevicol or fevistick on the smooth surface then place the egg on its long end, it will stick to that fevicol. you can also see as it stands on a smooth surface.
this might be the best way.

if it is not then tell us.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 25 ·
Replies
25
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K