Chiaroscuro photos with natural sunlight

  • Thread starter Andre
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Lighting
12 replies · 4K views · last reply
Andre
Messages
4,296
Reaction score
73
In the new photo contest the subject is

Chiaroscuro (italian) is a term in art for a contrast between light and dark. An another form is Rembrandt lighting. So this week, it is about the nicest picture of any brightly lit subject against a dark background.

So that elicited this comment:

junglebeast said:
Rembrandt lighting, eh? So photo tweaking is not allowed, but professional photography lighting rigs are recommended for entry?

...

So I like to answer to that with a few examples of Rembrandt lighting with an unprofessional onmipresent lighting rig, the sun. Now which one should I select?

Clear glass sphere resting on the edge of a block of ice, with dark green foliage and a reflection of trees visible inside the sphere.


Three young women posing together in a mirrored room, one in a patterned bikini top holding a small camera up to the mirror, with a watermark reading Atloviu(L) in the lower right corner.


Juvenile bald eagle in flight, seen from the side, with mottled brown and white plumage and a yellow beak, carrying a dark branch or stick in its talons against a blurred green background.


Squirrel monkey hanging upside down from a branch in dark, sunlit foliage, with its face and hands in shadow and its back lit by sun.


Cluster of blue-violet orchid flowers, likely Vanda, with mottled petals and white centres, set against dark green leaves.

(ok this one required a modest fill in flash)

Backlit allium seed heads with bright, glowing spherical clusters of thin stalks in the foreground against a dark green blurred background, with more seed heads behind.
 
Last edited:
Andre said:
In the new photo contest the subject is



So that elicited this comment:



So I like to answer to that with a few examples of Rembrandt lighting with an unprofessional onmipresent lighting rig, the sun. Now which one should I select?

Clear glass sphere resting on a block of ice, reflecting dark green foliage and a red-tinted background, with blurred greenery behind.


Three young women taking a mirror selfie in a tiled bathroom; the woman on the left holds up a phone, and a watermark reading Atloviu(L) appears in the corner.


Juvenile bald eagle in flight over blurred green forest, carrying a branch or stick in its talons, beak pointing left.


Squirrel monkey hanging upside down from a branch in dappled sunlight, its grey head and orange-yellow limbs lit against a dark green background.


Cluster of purple-blue orchid flowers with white-speckled petals and white centres, hanging among dark green leaves.

(ok this one required a modest fill in flash)

Backlit clusters of spherical seed heads on tall green stems in a grassy field, with a bright yellow-green head in the foreground and pinkish-white heads blurred behind.

I think the dandelion picture is gorgeous.. I'd vote for that one. Good quality, good composition.

I like the squirrel monkey too though haha But that's just because I like them :) The lighting is really good on the fur too.. it's a great pic.

So I'd say one of those two.. but that's just my 2 cents
 
None of these pictures shows Rembrandt lighting in any way -- Rembrandt lighting requires a human face.

It seems that you're just trying to pre-select your competition photo to increase your own odds of winning...

- Warren
 
The question was not Rembrandt lighting but:

the nicest picture of any brightly lit subject against a dark background.

But the message is clear. I will not enter anything in the contest.
 
Andre said:
The question was not Rembrandt lighting but

I'm just pointing out that you posted a few examples of Rembrandt lighting, yet none of your pictures show Rembrandt lighting.

For the record, you don't need professional lighting equipment to produce Rembrandt lighting. All you need to do is drape a bed sheet over a window and spend a few minutes posing your subject.

- Warren
 
Rembrandt lighting:

"The key light is placed high and to one side at the front, and the fill light or a reflector is placed half-height and on the other side at the front, set to about half the power of the key light, with the subject, if facing at an angle to the camera, with the key light illuminating the far side of the face. The key in Rembrandt lighting is creating the triangle or diamond shape of light underneath the eye...The triangle should be no longer than the nose and no wider than the eye"

I have a really cool picture of myself using Rembrandt lighting, but it was taken professionally and is not something I could emulate without having the reflector and lighting rigs.

And Andre -- stop taking things so seriously.
 
chroot said:
...Rembrandt lighting requires a human face.

Like this?

Painting of a small sailing ship with billowing sails tossed by stormy, churning waves under a dark, cloudy sky, with crew members clustered on deck and a man clinging to the mast.

source

Now where is the bedsheet over the window here?
 
I'm not sure what point you are trying to make as that Rembrandt painting is clearly not an example of Rembrandt lighting.
 
Rembrandt did not always use "Rembrandt lighting" in his paintings. Rembrandt lighting is a style of portraiture -- of the human face -- which Rembrandt often employed.

It is defined by the high key light and the resulting triangle of light on the opposite cheek.

Your own link to Wikipedia explains it well. Have you read it?

- Warren
 
chroot said:
Rembrandt did not always use "Rembrandt lighting" in his paintings. Rembrandt lighting is a style of portraiture -- of the human face -- which Rembrandt often employed.

It is defined by the high key light and the resulting triangle of light on the opposite cheek.

Your own link to Wikipedia explains it well. Have you read it?

- Warren

Rembrandt is known for his USE OF LIGHT in paintings. Not for 'Rembrandt lighting', that came after as an effect used in portraits... they named it after him because this style makes objects seem very deep and and natural by using light, which he was a master of. Regardless this form of lighting is done in portraits. Chiaroscuro however is just a style which uses contrasts of light/dark in any type of image.

Know all of this from taking 4 years of visual art courses and 2 art history courses :P
 
junglebeast said:
I'm not sure what point you are trying to make as that Rembrandt painting is clearly not an example of Rembrandt lighting.

So how about your entry in the contest?
 
Andre said:
So how about your entry in the contest?

What about it? The topic said Chiaroscuro, not Rembrandt lighting.

Also, what about this?

And Andre -- stop taking things so seriously.

This game is only getting less fun due to all the bickering and nonsensical rules.