Choosing the research area in physics

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around how individuals choose their research areas in physics, particularly for undergraduate students contemplating specialization. Participants explore factors influencing their decisions, such as personal interests, available opportunities, and the relevance of ongoing research at their institutions.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses uncertainty about how to choose a research area, highlighting a broad interest in theoretical physics, particularly in topics like Quantum Gravity and Quantum Computation.
  • Another suggests volunteering in research projects at the university to gain exposure to different fields and determine personal preferences.
  • A participant notes that their university's faculty primarily focuses on astrophysics and solid state physics, which do not align with their interests, although they have some engagement in Quantum Optics.
  • Concerns are raised about the lack of support from a professor on a project related to Open Quantum Systems, leading to frustration and uncertainty about pursuing this area further.
  • Some participants discuss the importance of exploring opportunities like Research Experiences for Undergraduates (REUs) and attending departmental colloquia to gain insights into various research fields.
  • One participant emphasizes that the choice of research area is influenced by a mix of opportunity, practicality, and personal interest.
  • There is a clarification that interest in General Relativity does not necessarily imply an interest in astrophysics, as some areas of astrophysics may not relate to GR.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of opinions on how to approach choosing a research area, with some advocating for exploration through available opportunities while others highlight the challenges posed by limited faculty support and specific interests. No consensus is reached on a singular method for making this decision.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention limitations such as the availability of faculty in specific research areas, the impact of attending a non-top-ranked university, and the challenges of balancing undergraduate coursework with self-directed studies.

ShayanJ
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Messages
2,802
Reaction score
605
I want to know how people usually choose their area of research?Is it just interest?What about choosing between areas which are all of your interest?
I know,it may seem weird for an undergrad to ask that,but I think its the time for me to decide on it.Because I started studying physics when I was in the middle of high school and now(that I'm an undergrad in physics)I'm in a place that I think I can almost understand some papers and so I think its time to specialize my studies on a particular subject because I now see if I don't do that,then I have an ocean of information to understand which seems terrifying.
I should say that I mean my self-studies because I also have my undergrad courses to deal with.But the choice of area also helps in choosing a proper field for my graduate school which is to come in the next year or maybe next two years.
About my own favorite areas of research, I can say that I like Quantum Gravity,alternatives to General Relativity,Quantum Computation,Measurement problem,Open Quantum Systems and Quantum Decoherence(and anything relating to foundations and philosophy of Quantum Mechanics),Quantum Field theory and Standard Model,Grand Unification Theories and Theories of Everything...wait...wow...I think its better to say I like Theoretical Physics!
So...any idea is appreciated...and yeah...maybe some of you are going to say just be a good boy and try to get good grades in your own courses...well...that's welcome too...but hard to get along with!
Thanks all
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Just see what research is being done at your university, and whatever seems most interesting, volunteer to help with. At least, that seems to be a common way to break into sub-fields. It also helps you know what you like/don't like early on enough that you won't get stuck in Graduate school on a project you hate.
 
Yeah...that's a good idea but there are some points about it.Professors in my university are either in astrophysics or solid state physics which are not of my interest much!
We also have professors in AMO Physics(Atomic, molecular, and optical physics). One of them is working on plasmas which again isn't of my interest much.
One other is working on Quantum Optics which is near to my interests in some cases and I already have a project with him.I should study a paper about Quantum trajectories which is a theory about Open Quantum Systems.It was because of this paper that I became interested in Open Quantum Systems.Only the trouble is that the professor doesn't help much.I don't know,maybe its because I'm "only" an undergrad!
But anyway,I'm working on this paper and trying to figure it out.But still not sure its the thing I really want to do research about!
 
Hmm. You've ruled out

-AMO
-Astrophysics
-Solid State

But you seem interested in Open Quantum Systems, and a prof just isn't working with you on the level you want? How long have you tried to collaborate? Just a single email?

What year are you in?

There might be REU's to apply for, have you tried searching through those?
 
Shyan said:
Yeah...that's a good idea but there are some points about it.Professors in my university are either in astrophysics or solid state physics

Solid state physics and astrophysics are my two main interests right now! Maybe I should go to your university ;)
 
HayleySarg said:
Hmm. You've ruled out

-AMO
-Astrophysics
-Solid State

But you seem interested in Open Quantum Systems, and a prof just isn't working with you on the level you want? How long have you tried to collaborate? Just a single email?

What year are you in?

There might be REU's to apply for, have you tried searching through those?

Well,its not that I don't like those three fields.I just like those, mentioned in my first post, more.And I've been trying to get cooperation from him for several weeks by phone and email and also in some meetings but he just postponed all things till someday he said go and study it all by yourself.And so I'm trying to do that.I'm in my fourth year but I may be obliged to stay more because I have failed some courses before.I also should say I'm not in US and not in a top rank university so there is no REU.
 
You should check out department colloquium from top schools like MIT, CalTech, Harvard, etc. They upload some of them online, just visit their website. This is a good way to get a brief intro into a specific research field, see what people are doing and what the big questions are. If there's many talks on similar subjects, you know it's a field that's making good progress! For the ones you find interesting, visit that professor's website to check out their publications, what people in his/her group are doing, etc.
 
I think the process is a serendipitous mix of opportunity (what people happen to be working on where you've chosen to study, what's popular at the time, what you happen to be reading), practical considerations (are you going to translate this into a job, can you get into a graduate school where this is studied), and of course interest (you tend to go with what you find most interesting among your viable options).

As an undergrad I think it's a perfect time to start reading up on those areas that you're interested in. Usually by your upper years you should be able to get something useful out of review articles, even if you can't follow all of the details. Try going through issues of Physics Today for example.

In addition to what Retro10x said, colloquia at your own school are worth attending.

It can also help to get to know some graduate students.
 
You like GR but you have no interest in astrophysics?
 
  • #10
Thanks people
And tom,astrophysics isn't just about GR!
For example one of the astrophysics professors in my university is working on the structure of sunspots which has nothing to do with GR.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
3K