Comoving distance, causality volume and entropy

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Xkcd
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Hello everyone !

I try to find the expression of the time derivative of the entropy for the CMB (photon gas) but I am stuck with the calculations.

We are in the matter-domination area and at the present time (Ro=1). No radiation and no vacuum, only the curvature. The different equations are:

Stack of cosmology equations: r_horiz as an integral of c/R dt/dR dR; r_horiz = 2c/(H0 Omega0) sqrt(R) sqrt(Omega0 + R(1 - Omega0)); entropy S = 4pi^2 k_B^4 VT^3/(45 c^3 hbar^3); V_horiz integral of x^2/sqrt(1 - k x^2); and dS/dt expression.


The problem is that the equations are resolved regardless of the spatial curvature of the universe. For the comoving distance I used :

Two equations: k = (H0^2 / c^2)(Omega0 - 1), and R-dot^2 = H0^2 (Omega0/R + 1 - Omega0).


But I cannot find the same result. I have

Equation for comoving distance: c over H0 times the square root of (Omega0 minus 1), times the integral from 0 to R of dR over the square root of (R^2(1 - Omega0) + R Omega0).


If I use a calculator I have an equation with logarithm and I do not find the previous result andI cannot find where is my mistake.

And I have a similar problem with the integral for the volume. With a calculator I have a monster with Arcsin and I cannot find the final expression for the entropy.

If someone could help me with the different steps for the two integrals so that I can find the expression for the derivative of the entropy.

Thank you !
 
Attachments
  • Stack of cosmology equations: r_horiz as an integral of c/R dt/dR dR; r_horiz = 2c/(H0 Omega0) sqrt(R) sqrt(Omega0 + R(1 - Omega0)); entropy S = 4pi^2 k_B^4 VT^3/(45 c^3 hbar^3); V_horiz integral of x^2/sqrt(1 - k x^2); and dS/dt expression.
    Eqcosmo.png
    10.7 KB · Views: 985
  • Two equations: k = (H0^2 / c^2)(Omega0 - 1), and R-dot^2 = H0^2 (Omega0/R + 1 - Omega0).
    Eqcosmo2.png
    3.1 KB · Views: 679
  • Equation for comoving distance: c over H0 times the square root of (Omega0 minus 1), times the integral from 0 to R of dR over the square root of (R^2(1 - Omega0) + R Omega0).
    Eqcosmo3.png
    2.8 KB · Views: 538
Why are you using equations for a horizon? There is no cosmological horizon in a matter-dominated universe.

For the time derivative of the entropy of the CMB photon gas, you just need the entropy of a photon gas (which is a function of its temperature), and how that photon gas evolves with time (which is pretty simple in a matter-dominated universe).