Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Comparing two sets of data with percentages

  1. Jan 20, 2012 #1
    Hi everyone,

    I was wondering if someone could help with the following:

    I am doing my undergraduate project and have collected two sets of answers following a survey, which I would like to compare.

    The questions (29 of them) are mostly Likert style, some allowing for multiple responses.

    I wanted to use percentages, but am not sure I can as area 1 n1=31 and area 2 n2=34. For example for one of the question the number of responses "I agree" were of one only in each area, which gave me the following percentages:
    area 1 = 3.2%; area 2 = 2.9 %
    So it seems that area 2 is under-represented.
    Can I still use percentages, is there anything to "adapt" my data? Or should I add n1 and n2 so 65 in which case I would get the same % per response, in the example cited above 1 response would equal to 1.5% in each case?

    Alternatively, a friend suggested a two sample t-test but if I remember properly this is for the mean, and I believe the median is more appropriate? Also, I would like to keep it as simple as possible to avoid biting more than I can chew really!

    Thank you very much, I hope that I made sense, I would appreciate an answer in as plain English as possible as I will get lost in the jargon otherwise!

    Carole
     
  2. jcsd
  3. Jan 22, 2012 #2

    Stephen Tashi

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    Give an example of a Likert style question I'm not sure what it is.

    Use percentages for what? What is it that you are trying to do?


    What characteristics make a number a correct representation? Without an explanation of the data and what you're tyring to analyze, I have no ideas on that subject.

    Why do you believe the median is more appropriate?

    If people in your field publish analyses of surveys, it would wise to look at published papers and reports and see what the authors did. In statistics, tradition often trumps any other consideration. If you are doing the analysis only for your own satisfaction, you have to formulate precisely what question your are asking.

    The Mann-Whitney U test is often used to test the hypothesis of the equality of two distributions. Equality of distributions is a more restrictive specification than merely saying that two distributions have the same median.
     
  4. Jan 23, 2012 #3
    Dear Stephen, thanks for your reply,




    I can try this, I have tried using Minitab to create some box-plots but I used it last three years ago and am now doing some trial and error to remember on how to input my data in the worksheet.

    I hope I made sense, thanks again,

    Carole
     
  5. Jan 23, 2012 #4

    Stephen Tashi

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    In my opinion, you haven't formed a precise statement of your objectives yet. You appear to have several objectives (which is perfectly OK). To use the traditional method of "hypothesis testing" you need a hypothesis! It must be specific. Different "null hypotheses" my require different statistical tests.

    Examples of various hypotheses

    1. There is no difference between the population of Clifton and City Centre with respect to the distribution of answers on the survey, if the entire population of each is polled.

    2. The population of Clifton has a higher fraction of people who answered a) to question 12 than the population of City Center

    3. When answering question 37, the population of Clifton tends to rate air quality as being higher than the poulation of City Center rates it.

    If you want to test a generality such as "The residents of Clifton are less concerned about environmental problems than the residents of City Centre" then you have to create a definition of that generality in terms of very specific hypotheses like those above.

    I think you are at the preliminary stage of analysis. You are using "descriptive statistics". The means you are making plots and graphs to form an intuitive understanding of the data. I'm sure that people have studied how to do this effectively - but I'm not one of them! As far as I know, there aren't any strict rules about what you must do. Perhaps papers in your field only publish informal arguments based on such descriptions.
     
  6. Jan 23, 2012 #5
    Dear Carole,

    Nothing comes to mind as to how to use medians instead of means to compare your data other than box diagrams etc, which are a good graphical aid to a project and take very little time to produce and write about, however witht he different populations I would probably lean more towards using the mean.

    I think your friends idea of a two sampled t-test is one of the better options. You will be able to conclude if there is a significant difference between the two areas for each of your questions, and using the extra information in the output I think you can find things estimate for difference. Plus as you have inputted the data already a 2 sample t-test ir very quick and can only aid you in your project :) As long as you test the data is normally distributed and test for equal variances first.

    Another test you may want to use 2 proportions test? You can see if the proportion in n1 is similar to that of n2, for example if the proportion of obese females is the same as the proportion of obese males. This might help with your issue of misrepresentation that you mentioned. This would also need the data to be normally distributed and have equal variances.

    If you do not have normally distributed data (I don't think this is likely for alot of the questions) the Mann Whitney U test can be used instead of the 2 sample t-test and is found in the Non-Parametric tests :)

    I hope this helped!
     
  7. Jan 24, 2012 #6
    Dear Stephen and Monachus,

    Thanks a lot to both of you for your help, I will go with the two sample t-test which appears to be the best option as advised by several parties.

    Thanks again,

    Kind regards,

    Carole
     
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook




Similar Discussions: Comparing two sets of data with percentages
Loading...