Comparison of T, E and V in different states?

3 replies · 1K views · last reply
theBEAST
Messages
361
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Multiple-choice question about a bomb in a steel box, comparing states 1 and 2, with options a to e; options a (Volume V2>V1) and e (Temperature T2>>T1) are checked.


The Attempt at a Solution


I currently think that a and e are correct. But I am not sure what happens to the energy IN THE BOX. When the box explodes, the energy of the contents changes from potential to thermal, sound and kinetic energy. Thus by conservation of energy there is no change in energy of the contents...

Am I right?

Thanks!
 
There's probably some debate room on a few of these. But why did you check a) if they specifically said in a box that will contain the explosion without deformation? And if you say there is no change in the energy inside the box, why didn't you check c)? Not sure I get the logic here. Surely ONE of b,c or d must be true? I mean they contain all possibilities.
 
Last edited:
Dick said:
There's probably some debate room on a few of these. But why did you check a) if they specifically said in a box that will contain the explosion without deformation? And if you say there is no change in the energy inside the box, why didn't you check c)? Not sure I get the logic here.

OH, I totally did not see that. Alright so the volume remains constant, and the temperature increases drastically. In those 0.1s, the energy is conserved so I will pick c and e.
 
theBEAST said:
OH, I totally did not see that. Alright so the volume remains constant, and the temperature increases drastically. In those 0.1s, the energy is conserved so I will pick c and e.

That's plausible and probably approximately correct. But if you've got sound energy generated inside the box it could probably get out in less that 0.1 sec, yes? This the 'debatable' thing.