Complex function, principal value notation

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Hill
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Complex function
5 replies · 2K views · last reply
Hill
Messages
867
Reaction score
658
TL;DR
Notations ##Log##, ##[]##
When a variable in ##[\text { } ]## means its principal value, ##(-\pi,\pi]##, which is correct:
##Log(z^2)=log([z]^2)## or ##Log(z^2)=log([z^2])## (both, neither)?
 
IMO, you are confused. It is the Log that returns the principle value, no matter what the input is. Also, regardless of what the input is, log() does not indicate the principle value. It is a multi-valued function.
## log( z) = ln |z| + i (Arg( z) + 2\pi k)## for ##k \in \mathbb I##.
So the right sides of your two alternative equations are multiple valued.
 
FactChecker said:
IMO, you are confused. It is the Log that returns the principle value, no matter what the input is. Also, regardless of what the input is, log() does not indicate the principle value. It is a multi-valued function.
## log( z) = ln |z| + i (Arg( z) + 2\pi k)## for ##k \in \mathbb I##.
So the right sides of your two alternative equations are multiple valued.
Thank you. This exercise is the source of my confusion:

Textbook exercise 27 on the complex logarithm: a derivation log[(-z)^2] = log[z^2] followed by steps using log(-z) + log(-z) = log(z) + log(z), then 2log(-z) = 2log(z), then log(-z) = log(z), with the question What is wrong with this argument?


What is a role of the square brackets in the first equation? They cannot mean principal values of ##z^2## and of ##(-z)^2## as these functions are single-valued.
 
@Hill , can you please explain the meaning of '[]'? Is it anything other than a placeholder?
 
WWGD said:
@Hill , can you please explain the meaning of '[]'? Is it anything other than a placeholder?
This is how it appears in the text:

Printed text describing the principal branch of the cube root: with this choice of theta, the single-valued function cube root of z times e^(i theta/3) is called the principal branch, written as [cube root of z], noting it agrees with the real cube root.
 
IMO, regardless of whether ##[z^2]## has the principle argument, ##Arg(z^2)##, the function ##log [z^2]## is multiple valued.