Confusing Derivation of torque acting on disk question

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
3 replies · 1K views
Bonbon32
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
A disk of mass M and angular speed w falls into table top. The kenetic coffienet of friction from table top is meu. Create an equation for dt=dr *F. Using this information.
Relevant Equations
Menu kenetic Mg = Friction
Iaplha = torque
Fr = torque
1577153780320.png

Not sure how they obtained an answer of (2meukenetic *Mg/R^2)*r^2 dr = dt
When they say disk I am assuming it's not ring shaped. So since F * Dr= DT where I guess F acting on a small point on the disc is constant from the table top. And Dr is the variable distance from a random small point from the axis which summed together times force give total torque. I plug in F friction using mgmeu. Not to sure where to go from there.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20191224_002338.jpg
    IMG_20191224_002338.jpg
    80 KB · Views: 251
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
The disk as a whole, lying on the tabletop, exerts a force ##M g## on the table surface, right? Assuming that the weight is evenly distributed over the entire disk-table interface, that means that the disk presents a pressure of ##Mg/\pi R^2##.

A given circular element of the disk will have an area associated with it (##\pi r^2 dr##). What is the force associated with that area element (you've got pressure and area)? Work out the ##d\tau## that that circular element will provide.
 
gneill said:
The disk as a whole, lying on the tabletop, exerts a force ##M g## on the table surface, right? Assuming that the weight is evenly distributed over the entire disk-table interface, that means that the disk presents a pressure of ##Mg/\pi R^2##.

A given circular element of the disk will have an area associated with it (##\pi r^2 dr##). What is the force associated with that area element (you've got pressure and area)? Work out the ##d\tau## that that circular element will provide.
Makes sense so (meu mg/R^2 )* r^2 *Dr which gives me a torque, not sure where they got the 2 from? Which is on the numerator next to the meu value. Finally got one more question if you can bear with me. Would the meu mg the friction be dF instead as we are taking only a small circular position about the rotating axis? So it becomes meu*dm*g ? If we aren't assuming anything.
 
Bonbon32 said:
Makes sense so (meu mg/R^2 )* r^2 *Dr which gives me a torque, not sure where they got the 2 from?
What's the area of the circular element of radius r and width dr?
1577156961543.png

Bonbon32 said:
Would the meu mg the friction be dF instead as we are taking only a small circular position about the rotating axis? So it becomes meu*dm*g ?
Force is pressure times area. so the frictional force contribution for a given area element becomes ##dF = P \times dA##, where dA is the differential area element.

By the way, you can find a table of mathematical letters and symbols in the edit window top bar menu if you click on the ##\sqrt{x}## icon. There you will find, for example, the Greek letter μ. You don't need to call it "meu", if you can use the actual letter.

[edit] Added an image to clarify what a "circular element" refers to.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Bonbon32