Confusion about a capacitor with 2 different dielectrics

4 replies · 5K views · last reply
Hieu
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
1. The problem statement, all variables, and given/known data
A parallel-plate capacitor has the space between the plates filled with to slabs of dielectric, one with constant K1, & one constant K2. each slab has thickness d⁄2, where d is plate separation, show the capacitance is?
Formula for capacitance: C = (2 epsilon_0 A / d) times (K1 K2 / (K1 + K2)), with a fraction in parentheses.

Homework Equations


C=Q/V
E=Q/(ε0.A)
mrqBvc

V=Q/(4πε0.r)

The Attempt at a Solution


I consider the conductor as 2 different conductors with different slabs of the dielectric. I think that is not a bad idea to find the answer, but my result is different from the answer, maybe it is wrong somewhere. Can you guys help me? Here is my solution.
Handwritten derivation of the capacitance of two dielectric slabs in series, with C = Q/V, C = 4πε0 d/2 and C1 = K1·C, C2 = K2·C, leading to Ceq = K1·K2·2πε0·d/(K1 + K2) in red.
 
Attachments
  • Formula for capacitance: C = (2 epsilon_0 A / d) times (K1 K2 / (K1 + K2)), with a fraction in parentheses.
    cramster-equation-2012241714286346397246825332121459.gif
    774 bytes · Views: 1,296
  • Handwritten derivation of the capacitance of two dielectric slabs in series, with C = Q/V, C = 4πε0 d/2 and C1 = K1·C, C2 = K2·C, leading to Ceq = K1·K2·2πε0·d/(K1 + K2) in red.
    27901128_940949156060953_1878984400_o.jpg
    22.9 KB · Views: 1,392
Hello. Welcome to PF!

The mistake is using the equation ##V = \large \frac{Q}{4\pi\epsilon_0 r}##. This is not applicable to parallel plates.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Hieu and Vriska
You can express V as a line integral over the E field. Try using: $$V=\int_0^d E(z)dz=\int_0^{\frac {d} {2}} E_1(z)dz +\int_{\frac {d} {2}}^{d} E_2(z)dz $$where ##E=\frac {\sigma} {K\epsilon_0}##, d is plate separation and ##\sigma## is the charge density.

Peace
Fred
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Hieu
Hi Hieu,

Your problem statement should be more specific about the geometric arrangement of the dielectric slabs between the plates. Do they divide the space horizontally or vertically? Given the expected answer we can deduce that the arrangement is two horizontal slabs dividing the space vertically (case B below), but it might be not so obvious to a new student approaching this type of problem for the first time.
Two schematic side views of a parallel-plate capacitor with dielectric slabs: Case A has k1 and k2 side by side, Case B has k1 stacked above k2. Case B is circled in red.
 
Attachments
  • Two schematic side views of a parallel-plate capacitor with dielectric slabs: Case A has k1 and k2 side by side, Case B has k1 stacked above k2. Case B is circled in red.
    upload_2018-2-9_11-11-18.png
    2.6 KB · Views: 1,297
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Hieu
Fred Wright said:
You can express V as a line integral...

There is a much easier way for an old duffer like me that involves knowing how to calculate the equivalent capacitance for two capacitors in series or parallel.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Hieu