This discussion centers on the philosophical implications of consciousness and reincarnation, questioning whether consciousness can arise from a state of unconsciousness. Participants argue that if consciousness exists before birth, it may be possible to regain consciousness after death, though this is debated. The conversation also touches on the physical nature of existence, suggesting that the atoms that comprise a person are constantly recycled, raising questions about identity and continuity after death. The potential scientific implications of reincarnation are also explored, referencing researchers like Ian Stevenson and Jim Tucker.
PREREQUISITESPhilosophers, psychologists, physicists, and anyone interested in the intersections of consciousness, identity, and the potential for reincarnation.
jarednjames said:All claims must be backed up by mainstream scienctific publications.
Overly speculative posts and personal theories are not allowed.
These are the forum guidelines.
jarednjames said:All claims must be backed up by mainstream scienctific publications.
Overly speculative posts and personal theories are not allowed.
These are the forum guidelines.
jarednjames said:Any post in philosophy regarding science or maths is subject to the same rules of the other forums. Philosophy forum rules, not mine.
The claims made are regarding a "life force" inside all living beings and the differences between being alive and dead. This is a Biology topic and better answers given in the biology forums for the claims made in those posts - to continue discussion here won't provide anything meaningful without someone who can give better input regarding the topic.
As per the posts themselves, they were an alternative hypothesis on the subject and they are specifically banned.
But hey, if the moderators feel the rules can be applied as they see fit and ignored where they don't wish to enforce them then so be it. It just lowers the quality of the forums.