Could dark matter be light

In summary, the conversation discusses whether light's energy can cause the bending of space-time and if that energy was accounted for in calculating the mass of the universe. It is suggested that gravity could potentially cause redshift in photons over time, but this theory has been disproven. The conversation also touches on the concept of "tired light," but this has not been supported by experiments.
  • #1
I was wondering two hings. First, does light's energy equate to mass and result in the bending of space time? The fact that it does follow the curve of space-time as well as mass-energy equivalence principle lead me to believe it would. Secondly, was that energy accounted for in calculating the mass of the universe(or whatever we did to figure there was dark matter)? Because that seems like it would be quite a few photons of really small energy that would add up to a lot of energy centered around where the most photon-emitting objects were.

and sort of extra: Thirdly, could the effects of gravity not cause enough loss of energy in photons traveling for such great distances to shorten their wavelengths and cause redshift, I didn't think we expected a constant energy level in anything else, why light, it should lose energy over time like anything else... eventually causing redshift and the farther away the object the more it would be red-shifted?
 
Phys.org - latest science and technology news stories on Phys.org
  • #2
Zula110100100 said:
I
and sort of extra: Thirdly, could the effects of gravity not cause enough loss of energy in photons traveling for such great distances to shorten their wavelengths and cause redshift, I didn't think we expected a constant energy level in anything else, why light, it should lose energy over time like anything else... eventually causing redshift and the farther away the object the more it would be red-shifted?

This point of view was put forth quite some time ago but was totally debunked; just doesn't work. Google "tired light".
 
  • #3
Zula110100100 said:
I was wondering two hings. First, does light's energy equate to mass and result in the bending of space time? The fact that it does follow the curve of space-time as well as mass-energy equivalence principle lead me to believe it would. Secondly, was that energy accounted for in calculating the mass of the universe(or whatever we did to figure there was dark matter)? Because that seems like it would be quite a few photons of really small energy that would add up to a lot of energy centered around where the most photon-emitting objects were.
Yeah, the only problem there is that we can observe photons. They make up about 0.001% of the energy density of the universe, far too little to explain dark matter.

Zula110100100 said:
and sort of extra: Thirdly, could the effects of gravity not cause enough loss of energy in photons traveling for such great distances to shorten their wavelengths and cause redshift, I didn't think we expected a constant energy level in anything else, why light, it should lose energy over time like anything else... eventually causing redshift and the farther away the object the more it would be red-shifted?
Lengthen their wavelengths (shortening their wavelengths would entail giving them more energy). But yes, this is exactly what happens. This is the normal redshift. As phinds mentions, some have proposed some ways that light might lose extra energy, in addition to the normal redshift. But these "tired light" scenarios have failed to agree with experiment.
 

Suggested for: Could dark matter be light

Replies
23
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
0
Views
700
Replies
1
Views
6K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
26
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
13
Views
1K
Back
Top