Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around finding software or software packages capable of solving the Euler-Lagrange field equations for manifestly-covariant Lagrangian densities in full tensor form. Participants explore various tools and configurations, particularly focusing on the use of Mathematica and the xAct package for tensor algebra.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Exploratory
- Homework-related
Main Points Raised
- One participant inquires about software that can handle the Euler-Lagrange equations for manifestly-covariant Lagrangians, noting their lack of experience with analytical computation software.
- Another participant requests a simple covariant Lagrangian example in LaTeX to demonstrate the desired computations.
- A participant suggests the Maxwell Lagrangian in curved spacetime as a suitable example but clarifies that they are more interested in the general capability of software rather than solving this specific case.
- There is a mention of the xAct package for tensor algebra as a potential tool, with a link provided for further exploration.
- One participant seeks advice on configuring xAct to simplify expressions, noting discrepancies between their results and those of another participant.
- A suggestion is made to adjust settings in xAct to achieve desired simplifications, including options for handling metrics and renaming indices for compactness.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally agree on the utility of the xAct package for their needs, but there are variations in individual experiences and results when using the software. The discussion remains open regarding specific configurations and outcomes.
Contextual Notes
Some limitations are noted regarding the participants' familiarity with software and the specific configurations that may affect the results. The discussion does not resolve the practicalities of applying the software to different Lagrangian forms.