Depth of fields in Physics, Cosmology etc

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
narrator
Messages
241
Reaction score
17
As someone trained in IT, having spent 15+ years as a network consultant, it sometimes surprises me that people expect you to be an expert in other areas of IT. I know networks and subnets, protocols, infrastructure, network security, data packets, switching, wireless and related things - that was my expertise (until I changed direction a few years ago). But people expect an IT person to also be expert in MS Office, Linux, Multimedia, Mac, telephony, databases, computer circuitry, business packages, etc. And while I know a lot about those things, they are not my field of expertise.

Is it the same within specific fields of science? Is a cosmologist more expert in one area of cosmology than another area of cosmology? I imagine there are physicist with expertise in different areas. Do biologists often find themselves explaining that the area of inquiry is not in their field of expertise?
 
Old thread but worthwhile question that I have also wondered. Is there a danger in the increasing specialization of science? When we have scientists working so narrowly in a field, who is there to connect all the dots?
 
The degree of labor specialization is determined by the level of demand - A. Smith
 
PhD Comics chart titled 'What You Know vs How much you know about it': a red downward line from Everything at top-left to Nothing at bottom-right, with points Undergrad, Master's, and Ph.D., and the note 'Oops! You overshot it!' at the bottom.

http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1056
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: EnumaElish and Greg Bernhardt
Greg Bernhardt said:
but worthwhile question
When no one can understand you, you have ceased to be relevant.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: EnumaElish