Deriving Snell's Law

  • Level: High School 
  • Thread starter WheatNeat
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Snell's law
1 reply · 2K views · last reply
WheatNeat
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
TL;DR
Why are perpendiculars used to compare the two paths, and where does this angle approximation come from?
Here we are deriving snell's law. The text compares the length of the two paths (which are assumed to be close enough such that the time difference is negligible), and uses the perpendicular to compare them. They should technically be making an isoceles triangle to compare them right? Is this an approximation? Also the text says that angle FCX is approximately equal to angle BCN', but this doesn't seem to be true in the limit as X approaches C. What am I missing?

Diagram of Fermat's principle for refraction: points A and B on opposite sides of a horizontal air-water boundary, with normal line NN' through point C, and point X on the boundary; perpendiculars from C and X to the rays are labelled E and F, with the caption 'Fig. 26-4. Illustration of Fermat's principle for refraction.'


Printed text from a physics textbook on Fermat's principle, with handwritten red annotation reading 'in air' above 'on land' and a red arc over the words. The text compares path lengths XE, EC, CF and XF and the times along them, and introduces a speed of 1/n times in water.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
WheatNeat said:
TL;DR Summary: Why are perpendiculars used to compare the two paths, and where does this angle approximation come from?

Here we are deriving snell's law. The text compares the length of the two paths (which are assumed to be close enough such that the time difference is negligible), and uses the perpendicular to compare them. They should technically be making an isoceles triangle to compare them right? Is this an approximation?
Yes, that's right. You can show that the error associated with this approximation is of order higher than first order. So, it's ok.

WheatNeat said:
Also the text says that angle FCX is approximately equal to angle BCN', but this doesn't seem to be true in the limit as X approaches C. What am I missing?

Label the angles as shown.
Geometry diagram of light refraction: a horizontal x-axis through point C, a vertical normal N' below C, point X on the axis with perpendicular drops XE and XF, point B below right, and labeled angles phi, theta 2 and epsilon.

The angle ε is small of first order when distance XC is small compared to distance CB.

Show that ##\phi = \theta_2 + \varepsilon##. So, as X approaches C, ##\phi## differs from ##\theta_2## to first order. However, you are interested in the distance ##XF##, which equals ##XC \sin \phi##. Since ##XC## is already a small, first order quantity, ##XC\sin \phi## will be accurate to first order if you use the "zeroth order" approximation ##\phi \approx \theta_2##.