Determine energy state difference using absorption-emission spectra

3 replies · 3K views · last reply
JoJoQuinoa
Messages
17
Reaction score
0
Hello,

I was wondering if someone could help clarifying this question.

The question asks to estimate the energy state difference between the vibrational ground state of S0,v=0 and the first excited vibrational ground state S0,v=1 of the spectra below.

The given solution: S1,v=1 -> S0,v=1 at [itex]\lambda[/itex] = 400 nm and S1,v=2 -> S0,v=1 at [itex]\lambda[/itex] = 380 nm.

There are two things I'm confused about the solution:
1) From Figure B, I would assume that the first Fluorescence peak at 380 nm in Figure A corresponds to S1,v=0 -> S0,v=1 and the second peak at 400 nm corresponds to S1,v=0 -> S0,v=2. Larger transition results in higher emission energy or smaller wavelength.

2) Why is S0,v=1 being used as the final state for both peaks?
The S1,v=1 -> S0,v=1 would occur as S1,v=1 ->S1,v=0 ->S0,v=1 and
S1,v=2 ->S1,v=0 ->S0,v=1.
Since S1,v=2 or 1 ->S1,v=0 is internal conversion, wouldn't S1,v=0 ->S0,v=1 for the two transitions give off the same energy?

Thanks in advance!
Graph of absorbance (blue curve) and fluorescence intensity (black curve) against wavelength from 300 to 480 nm for anthracene, with its structure shown; absorption peaks are at lower wavelengths than the fluorescence peaks.
Energy diagram of fluorescence and absorption transitions between vibrational levels of two electronic states, with Gaussian-shaped spectral bands plotted against energy; fluorescence labelled 0 to 2, 0 to 1, 0 to 0, 0 to 3, 0 to 4, 0 to 5, 0 to 6, and absorption labelled 2 to 0, 1 to 0, 0 to 0, 3 to 0, 4 to 0, 5 to 0, 6 to 0.
 
I don't think the solution matches what the question asks for. Could you write the fully replicated question and the solution? Perhaps, a screenshot/photo of the question and solution?

For example, the question asks for the energy state difference, which means that the solution should be in the units of eV or cm-1 (or Hartree). It doesn't make any sense that the solution is in wavelength (nm) because wavelength is inversely proportional to energy and is not linear. Thus, you can't just add/subtract wavelength differences (unless you know what you are doing).

Also,
1) No, the fluorescence peak at 380 is not S1,v=0 → S0,v=1, and the second peak at 400 nm is not S1,v=0 → S0,v=2. What is your reasoning that you are not seeing any v=0→0 transition?
 
Hi Hayao,
Thank you for your response!

The question was: Use the anthracene absorption and emission spectrum in Figure 8.5 (Figure 1 in this post) to construct a combined Jablonski diagram/absorption/emission spectrum sketch. Label all states and calculate transition energies in cm-1.

The solution provided by the Professor and the one I found on Google were similar and as provided in the original post: S1,v=1 -> S0,v=1 at λ = 400 nm and S1,v=2 -> S0,v=1 at λ = 380 nm. I believe both were mislabeled. I found the figure below from ScienceDirect and I think it is correct.

"No, the fluorescence peak at 380 is not S1,v=0 → S0,v=1, and the second peak at 400 nm is not S1,v=0 → S0,v=2. What is your reasoning that you are not seeing any v=0→0 transition?"

Initially, I labeled the first peak as v=0->0 (overlapping peaks in Absorption and Emission spectrum are v=0->0 transition) and second peak to be v=0->1. I got confused by the solution and modified my answer.

Combined Jablonski diagram and anthracene absorption/emission spectrum: molecular structure, S0 to S1 and T1 vibronic energy levels, and labelled transitions over 300 to 750 nm.