Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Direct simple solution of the envelopes paradox

  1. Dec 19, 2006 #1


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper

    The proposed (in)equality is A >=< p2A 2A + pA/2 A/2. Since the two amounts are either "A" and "2A," or "A" and "A/2," p2A > 0 implies pA/2 = 0, and vice versa. Therefore p2ApA/2 = 0. If pA/2 > 0 then

    pA/2 A >=< pA/2p2A 2A + pA/22 A/2

    pA/2 A >=< pA/22 A/2

    A >=< pA/2 A/2

    Clearly A > pA/2 A/2, and one would not switch.

    Alternatively, if p2A > 0 then

    p2A A >=< p2A2 2A + p2ApA/2 A/2

    p2A A >=< p2A2 2A

    A >=< p2A 2A

    1/2 >=< p2A, and one would switch only if 1/2 < p2A. Taking p2A = 1/2 in the original problem as a given, one would not switch.

    [Edit: this does not work in the general case where the values are kA and A/k with k > 2.]
    Last edited: Dec 20, 2006
  2. jcsd
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Can you offer guidance or do you also need help?
Draft saved Draft deleted