The Brachistochrone Problem: cycloid curve

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
physicsbeginnerss
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
Show, in Figure 4.4, that for a point like P3, x3/y3 > π/2 and for P2, x2/y2 = π/2.
Relevant Equations
$$\frac{y1}{x1}>\frac{P2A}{AO}=\frac{2a}{a\pi}=\frac{2}{\pi}$$
This is 'Boas mathematical Methods in the Physical Sciences' homework p484.(Calculus of Variations)

problem2 section4 number 2

Cycloid curve from O to B with a rolling circle of diameter 2a at its lowest point P2 below top point A; x1, y1 mark point P1 on the arc, and P3 lies on the arc near B.

The bead is rolling on the cycloid curve.(Figure 4.4)
And the book explain that
'Then if the right-hand endpoint is (x, y) and the origin is
the left-hand endpoint, we can say that the bead just slides down, or slides down and
back up, depending on whether x/y is less than or greater than π/2 (Problem 2).'

My question is how can be it's just slides down or slides down and back up depending on
the magnitude of x/y? I mean it's depending on potential energy that it back up with origin height.(That contains origin potential energy)

The book explains when it comes to P2 the circle has rolled halfway around so OA=$$\frac{1}{2}\cdot 2a\pi=a\pi$$.
For any point P1 on arc
OP2, P1 is below the line OP2, and the coordinates (x1, y1) of P1 have
$$\frac{y_1}{x_1}>\frac{P2A}{AO}=\frac{2a}{a\pi}=\frac{2}{\pi}$$ or $$x_1/y_1 < π/2$$.

And p3 is applied by same solution that x3/y3 would be greater than $$frac{\pi}{2}$$.

Here is my understanding.

Hand-drawn diagram of a cycloid arc from origin O, with the arc from O to P2 and P3 marked, a horizontal line from O, a vertical line labelled 2a, arc length labelled πa, and points P1(x1, y1), P2(x2, y2), P3(x3, y3).

This is what papers says and I drewed it and understand how it works.

But if $$\frac{x_3}{y_3}$$ is less than $$\frac{\pi}{2}$$
Hand-drawn sketch of a cycloid-like curve from point O on the left to point A at the top, with a straight chord O to a point on the right. A bump peaks at P2 beneath A, with labels P1 and P3 on the lower arcs and faint construction lines below.

In this curve it's hard for the bead back up to p3, But!, Is this can satified with the parametric equation of cycloid?
## $$x=a(\theta-sin\theta)$$
## $$y=a(1-cos\theta)$$

My question is can the last picture be satisfied with the parametric equation of a cycloid or not? And if not, what is the alternative solution that $$\frac{x_3}{y_3}$$ less than $$\frac{\pi}{2}$$ that is still cycloid curve.
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn sketch of a cycloid-like curve from point O at the left, dipping, rising to a peak at P2 under a horizontal line, then dipping again toward P3 on the right; handwritten text below reads: If x3/y3 is less than pi/2 it is impossible to back up to P3, but is this curve still follow the parametric equation of cycloid?
    KakaoTalk_20200628_210906879.jpg
    28.5 KB · Views: 247
  • Handwritten sketch of a cycloid-like curve from point O down to a valley and up over a bump at P2 then down to P3, with a chord O to A to the right, and the handwritten note: If x3/y3 is less than P2 it is impossible to back up to P3.
    000000.jpg
    33.4 KB · Views: 247
Last edited by a moderator:
PeroK said:
Can you fix your Latex? Use double dollar signs.
I just did it.
 
physicsbeginnerss said:
Then if the right-hand endpoint is (x, y) and the origin is
the left-hand endpoint, we can say that the bead just slides down, or slides down and
back up, depending on whether x/y is less than or greater than π/2
Perhaps it is intended as a purely kinematic observation. If the point of contact at some instant is at (x, y) (y measured positive down from the origin) then:
if x/y < π/2 the bead is still on the downward slope
if x/y > π/2 the bead has started back up
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: physicsbeginnerss