Does the comparison test prove this series diverges?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bachelier
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Divergence Series
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
3 replies · 2K views
Bachelier
Messages
375
Reaction score
0
[tex]\sum (n^2-arctan(n)) / (n^3 + sin(n))[/tex] n=0 to ∞

I know this series diverges, but how would you use the comparison test to compare it to (n^2 / n^3 meaning the harmonic series 1/n)

Thank you very much
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
[itex]|sin(n)|\le 1|[/itex] so the denominator can be replaced by [itex]n^3+ 1> n[/itex]. [itex]0\le arctan(n)\le 2\pi[/itex] so the numerator can be replaced by [itex]n^2- 2\pi< n^2[/itex].
 
HallsofIvy said:
[itex]|sin(n)|\le 1|[/itex] so the denominator can be replaced by [itex]n^3+ 1> n[/itex]. [itex]0\le arctan(n)\le 2\pi[/itex] so the numerator can be replaced by [itex]n^2- 2\pi< n^2[/itex].

Thanks for the reply

I thought [itex]- \pi/2\le arctan(n)\le \pi/2[/itex] for one

and two, based on your reasoning, our series will end up being smaller than [itex]n^3/n^2 = n[/itex] which in turn diverges, therefore this test is inconclusive. :confused:

And the denominator [itex]n^3 + sin(n)[/itex] will make the whole series bigger that a series with a denominator of [itex]n^3+ 1[/itex] but having a numerator that is smaller than the numerator of the second series with the denominator of [itex]n^3+ 1[/itex], will make it hard to decide which series is bigger.

thank you
 
Call the nth term of the series an. Then you know limit n*an as n->infinity is 1, right? Compare the series with 1/(2n) for sufficiently large n.