Doppler effect guitar string fundamental vs second harmonic

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
2 replies · 2K views
vetgirl1990
Messages
85
Reaction score
3

Homework Statement


A guitar player is plucking a strong of length 30cm. How fast must the player move towards or away from the stationary observer, in order for the observer to mistake the fundamental frequency for the second harmonic?

ANSWER: 2(Vsound) towards the observer

Homework Equations


Frequency for string fixed on both ends: f = 2n/vL
Doppler effect for source moving towards stationary observer (observer will hear higher frequency):
f" = vsound / vsound - Vsource

The Attempt at a Solution


f = 2n/vL = 2(1) / 343(0.3) = 205.8 Hz for the fundamental frequency --> set as f in the doppler equation
f = 2(2) / 343(0.3) = 411.5Hz for the second harmonic --> set as f" in the doppler equation

411.6 = 343 (205.8) / (343-vsound)
Vsound = 171.5 m/s = 1/2 vsound

I am getting 1/2 the speed of sound, rather than 2x the speed of sound which is the answer. What am I doing wrong?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
vetgirl1990 said:
I am getting 1/2 the speed of sound, rather than 2x the speed of sound which is the answer. What am I doing wrong?
Twice the speed of sound is clearly nonsense. The observer would not hear the player approach. Must be a typo.
Your answer looks right.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vetgirl1990
haruspex said:
Twice the speed of sound is clearly nonsense. The observer would not hear the player approach. Must be a typo.
Your answer looks right.

LOL thank you! My initial reaction to the "answer" was that it was an extremely hypothetical situation. Thanks for verifying!