Doubt about the behavior of a string of a piano

In summary, the conversation discusses two doubts regarding the vibrations and sound produced by a piano string. The first doubt is about the decay of the vibration over time and its relationship to the fundamental frequency. The second doubt is about the relationship between the fundamental frequency and its multiples in terms of sound intensity. The conversation also touches on the spectrum of sound produced by a piano string and the difference between overtones and harmonics. The concept of inharmonicity is also mentioned in relation to the departure of overtones from exact harmonics.
  • #1
Bruno Tolentino
97
0
Two doubts:

First, when the hammer hits any string, the string begins to vibrate, until here, no problems, but, the vibration decays over time and this decay is linear, exponential or assume another form?

Second, when the hammer hits a string and the string begins to vibrate, it vibrates in fundamental frequency, in resonance frequency, and we heard this vibration. But we heard other vibrations too, that is mutiples of the fundamental frequency.

So, when the hammer hits the string of 440 Hz, for example, we heard vibrations in 440 Hz, 880 Hz, 1320 Hz, 1760 Hz, 2200 Hz and so on. But in terms of sound intensity, what is the relationship between the fundamental frequency and the multiple of the fundamental frequency? I ask this because the amplitude of the multiple of the fundamental frequency is not equal the amplitude of the fundamental frequency. Probably, shoud exist a decaying relationship between the amplitude of the fundamental and its multiples.

EDIT: See this ilustration (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a4/Espectro_harmónico.jpg), but I don't know if this graphic is correct or not.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The decay in loudness will be basically exponential but it will not be a simple exponential decay because the various overtones may well decay at different rates.
As for the actual spectrum of the sound from a piano string, there have been many threads on PF about this. The one in this link is very long and rambling but could be worth reading through before continuing here on this thread. Basically, a plucked (or struck) string will start off in a certain shape (triangular, for instance) and the resulting vibrations will be a combination of all the natural modes of vibration of the string. (no other frequencies will be sustained) The proportions of each of the frequencies will depend upon where the string was actually struck. In a piano, you have no control over that but a guitar can be plucked anywhere and a whole range of tonal colours can be obtained. The amplitudes of the overtones will depend on the initial shape but the fundamental is normally the highest. The decay rates will depend very much on the design of the piano and strings; it won't be calculable.
I use the word Overtone, rather than Harmonic because the frequencies of the modes are not necessarily exact harmonics of the fundamental. This is what makes a real instrument sound real, as opposed to some of the more crude synthesised sounds that are based on harmonics. As it happens, the overtones and harmonics on strings are not too different. In brass instruments, they are wildly different - so much so that a good brass player has to 'pull' the higher notes significantly for them to sound right when playing in high registers.
 
  • Like
Likes Bruno Tolentino
  • #3
The departure of overtones from exact harmonics mentioned by sophiecentaur is discussed in the linked thread, but as far as I could see, not named there. For the record, it is called inharmonicity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inharmonicity
 
  • Like
Likes sophiecentaur

Q1: What causes a piano string to produce a different sound than usual?

There could be several reasons for this, including the string being out of tune, a problem with the internal mechanisms of the piano, or damage to the string itself. A thorough examination of the piano and its components would need to be done to determine the exact cause.

Q2: Can a piano string's behavior change over time?

Yes, a piano string's behavior can change over time. Factors such as temperature, humidity, and wear and tear can affect the tension and stiffness of the string, which can impact its sound and behavior.

Q3: How does the length of a piano string affect its behavior?

The length of a piano string directly affects its pitch and resonance. Longer strings produce lower pitches, while shorter strings produce higher pitches. The length of the string also affects its tension and stiffness, which can impact its behavior.

Q4: Can a piano string's material affect its behavior?

Yes, the type of material used for a piano string can greatly impact its behavior. Different materials have different densities, tensions, and stiffness, which can all affect the sound and behavior of the string.

Q5: What can be done to fix a piano string with unusual behavior?

The best course of action would be to have a professional piano technician examine the string and make any necessary adjustments or repairs. They may need to tune the string, adjust its tension, or replace it entirely if it is damaged.

Similar threads

  • Art, Music, History, and Linguistics
Replies
18
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
8K
Back
Top