ΔU, Q, W of thermodynamic process

4 replies · 8K views · last reply
Any Help
Messages
79
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


A monatomic ideal gas undergoes the thermodynamic process shown in the PV diagram. Determine whether each of the values ΔU, Q, and W for the gas is positive, negative, or zero.
PV diagram of a straight line segment falling from pressure 2P0 at volume V0 to pressure P0 at volume 2V0, with an arrow on the line pointing up and to the left, dashed guides to the axis labels.

Homework Equations


ΔU=Q-W
W=integral under the curve
PV=nRT T=PV/nR

The Attempt at a Solution


direction is negative then the integral negative then work is negative
ΔU depends on change in temp, and here pressure increases and volume decreases so it was Ti=P0x2V0/nR and at final it becomes Tf=2P0xV0/nR Tf=Ti then it stays the same no change in temp then ΔU =0
therefore 0=Q-W Q=W but W negative then Q also negative
Is that correct? I need only to check my answer...
and is there any other way to determine Q from Graph (without looking at W or ΔU) ?
 
Any Help said:
Is that correct? I need only to check my answer...
Yes.

Any Help said:
and is there any other way to determine Q from Graph (without looking at W or ΔU) ?
You could draw adiabats, one passing through point ##2V_0,P_0## and one through point ##V_0,2P_0##, and see if you are going closer to the origin (##Q<0##) or farther away from the origin (##Q>0##), but it is easier to calculate it as you did.
 
DrClaude said:
draw adiabats
how we draw them? do you mean to draw hyperbolas passing through them?
 
I mean that you draw the curves ##P = V^{-\gamma}## that pass through the given points.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Any Help
Careful with how W is defined. Physicists usually take W as the work done BY the gas, which is what you did & that's correct.

But chemists often (or usually?) take W as the work done ON the gas in which case your W would be positive and the 1st law would read ΔU = Q + W.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Any Help