Einstein theory on bending of space

In summary, according to Einstein's theory, it is the bending (more precisely, curvature) of space-time, not just space, that is responsible for gravity. This is a more complex theory than Newton's, and is only accessible to a select few college-level students or higher.
  • #36
PeterDonis said:
Einstein's attempt at Unified Field Theory only covered electromagnetism; the strong and weak forces were not well understood at that time and he didn't include them.

Yes. The theory that unifies the strong, weak, and EM interactions is called the Standard Model of particle physics. It does not include gravity (see further comments below on why).

Not really; it affects the difficulty of incorporating gravity into a quantum field theory, but GR is a classical theory, and at the classical level there is no problem with gravity being spin-2; as I think I said before, it's that which makes the GR model of gravity as spacetime curvature possible.

Not really; Einstein sort of intended it to be one, but, as above, he didn't include the strong and weak interactions, and he also didn't take quantum effects into account--during the latter part of his career he became very dissatisfied with quantum theory, even though he had helped to create the field.

"Entirely reconciled" is too strong, and I didn't mean to give that impression. There are several issues:

(1) Gravity, as an interaction, is so weak compared to the others that we have no way of experimentally detecting any quantum aspects that it might have. So we have no way of experimentally confirming that gravitons exist or investigating their properties. We basically believe they exist because all the other interactions have quantum aspects. But there are a number of physicists (Freeman Dyson, who was instrumental in the development of quantum field theory, is one of them) who question whether gravity really has to have quantum aspects the way the other interactions do. Without experimental input there is really no way of resolving this question.

(2) Constructing a quantum field theory of a spin-2 particle has issues that constructing a quantum field theory of particles with spin-1 or lower (which all of the particles in the Standard Model are) does not. The main one is that the QFT of a spin-2 particle is not renormalizable. For a detailed discussion of this we would really need to start a separate thread in the Quantum Physics forum, but the key point is that the Standard Model is entirely renormalizable, and that is an important feature. So there isn't a simple, obvious way to add gravitons to the Standard Model; doing that would break an important feature of the theory.

(3) Even if we assume that finding a quantum theory that includes gravity is the right way to go, it's not entirely clear that doing it by constructing a QFT including a spin-2 graviton along the same lines as the Standard Model is the way to do it. There are a number of different candidates for a quantum gravity theory being investigated, and we don't know at this point how that will play out. (The lack of experimental input is a big issue here.)

When Hawking talks about a Theory of Everything, he's talking about getting all these issues resolved. He's gone back and forth over the years about how close he thinks we are to actually doing it. I personally think we still have quite a way to go.
I really do appreciate the thorough explanation you have presented, Peter. It is exceptionally clear and informative.

The link to the Standard Model is a pleasant surprise. I've seen casual reference to the term before, but took it as a generic phrase for any early science. I had no idea it was a modern specific theory. I am incredibly naive sometimes.

Wes
...
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #37
Wes Tausend said:
I really do appreciate the thorough explanation you have presented, Peter. It is exceptionally clear and informative.

Thanks! Glad it was helpful.
 
<h2>What is Einstein's theory on bending of space?</h2><p>Einstein's theory on bending of space, also known as the general theory of relativity, states that mass and energy can cause a curvature in the fabric of space-time, which we experience as gravity. This theory revolutionized our understanding of gravity and has been confirmed by numerous experiments and observations.</p><h2>How does this theory explain the bending of light?</h2><p>According to Einstein's theory, massive objects like stars and galaxies create a curvature in space-time. When light passes through this curved space, it also follows the curvature, causing it to appear as though it is bending. This effect has been observed during solar eclipses, where the light from distant stars appears to bend as it passes near the sun's massive gravitational field.</p><h2>What evidence supports Einstein's theory on bending of space?</h2><p>One of the most famous pieces of evidence for Einstein's theory is the observation of gravitational lensing, where the light from distant galaxies is bent by the gravitational pull of massive objects in the foreground. This effect has been observed and confirmed through various experiments and observations, providing strong support for the theory.</p><h2>How does this theory relate to the concept of space-time?</h2><p>Einstein's theory of general relativity combines the concepts of space and time into a single entity called space-time. According to this theory, the presence of mass and energy can cause a curvature in space-time, which we experience as gravity. This revolutionary idea has greatly influenced our understanding of the universe.</p><h2>Can Einstein's theory on bending of space be tested?</h2><p>Yes, Einstein's theory has been extensively tested and confirmed through various experiments and observations. For example, the bending of light during solar eclipses, the precession of Mercury's orbit, and the observation of gravitational waves are all phenomena that have been predicted and observed based on this theory. Its accuracy and predictive power have made it one of the most well-supported theories in physics.</p>

What is Einstein's theory on bending of space?

Einstein's theory on bending of space, also known as the general theory of relativity, states that mass and energy can cause a curvature in the fabric of space-time, which we experience as gravity. This theory revolutionized our understanding of gravity and has been confirmed by numerous experiments and observations.

How does this theory explain the bending of light?

According to Einstein's theory, massive objects like stars and galaxies create a curvature in space-time. When light passes through this curved space, it also follows the curvature, causing it to appear as though it is bending. This effect has been observed during solar eclipses, where the light from distant stars appears to bend as it passes near the sun's massive gravitational field.

What evidence supports Einstein's theory on bending of space?

One of the most famous pieces of evidence for Einstein's theory is the observation of gravitational lensing, where the light from distant galaxies is bent by the gravitational pull of massive objects in the foreground. This effect has been observed and confirmed through various experiments and observations, providing strong support for the theory.

How does this theory relate to the concept of space-time?

Einstein's theory of general relativity combines the concepts of space and time into a single entity called space-time. According to this theory, the presence of mass and energy can cause a curvature in space-time, which we experience as gravity. This revolutionary idea has greatly influenced our understanding of the universe.

Can Einstein's theory on bending of space be tested?

Yes, Einstein's theory has been extensively tested and confirmed through various experiments and observations. For example, the bending of light during solar eclipses, the precession of Mercury's orbit, and the observation of gravitational waves are all phenomena that have been predicted and observed based on this theory. Its accuracy and predictive power have made it one of the most well-supported theories in physics.

Similar threads

  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
41
Views
3K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
16
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
13
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
40
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
21
Views
4K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
7
Views
943
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
22
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
14
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
3
Replies
81
Views
7K
Back
Top