Electron-positron annihilation diagram

7 replies · 6K views · last reply
CAF123
Gold Member
Messages
2,918
Reaction score
87
Just a quick question regarding the tree level Feynman diagram(s) contributing to this process - I am wondering if I wanted to compute the unpolarised transition amplitude for the annihilation ##e^+ e^- \rightarrow \gamma \gamma##, are there two tree level diagrams that contribute or just one?

I am thinking of an electron and positron as initial state, an electron/positron being the virtual particle and the two photons as the external state. (e.g photon a) tagged at vertex with the electron b) and another photon c) tagged at vertex with positron d)) That's one diagram. But I also thought, to take into account the bose symmetry, I would also need to consider an another diagram where photon a) is tagged at vertex with positron d) and another where photon c) is tagged at vertex with electron b)?

Is it correct?
 
Feynman diagram of electron-positron annihilation: an incoming electron e- and incoming positron e+ meet at a vertex, and two wavy photon lines labelled gamma emerge. Arrows labelled time (upward) and space (rightward) show the axes.

... what was the question?
 
Hi SimonBridge,

I have drawn what I think are the two contributing tree level processes for ##e^+ e^- \rightarrow 2\gamma##. I want to understand why we don't consider the ##t-## channel diagram on the left to be different from the ##u## channel diagram on the right.

Thanks!
 
Attachments
  • Two Feynman diagrams for electron-positron annihilation into two photons: left, e+ and e- lines meet at a vertex with an internal fermion line, photons k1 and k2 emitted; right, same process with the photons attached in the opposite order along the fermion line.
    diphoton.png
    3.1 KB · Views: 4,358
CAF123 said:
I want to understand why we don't consider the t− channel diagram on the left to be different from the u channel diagram on the right.

Who is doing this? I think you indeed have to consider both diagrams. But this is not exclusive to bosons, you would also get two diagrams of this kind with outgoing (indistinguishable) fermions.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: CAF123
Of course, in the leading (tree-level) order there are the two diagrams you draw, and that's indeed important to fulfill Bose symmetry for the outgoing photons. The diagrams are ##t##- and ##u##-channel diagrams.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: CAF123 and BvU
Ok, many thanks for the confirmation - it is as I thought. So, if I was computing the (unpolarised) transition amplitude for this process I would sum the amplitudes for each of the t and u channel processes? Then a probability would be the square of this:

$$P(e^+ e^- \rightarrow 2 \gamma) = \frac{1}{4} \sum_{\text{spins,polarisations}} |\mathcal M_1+ \mathcal M_2|^2$$
 
Ok thanks, I am aware of a crossing symmetry that exists between the unpolarised transition probability for compton scattering ##(e^- + \gamma \rightarrow e^- + \gamma)## and that for the case of diphoton production. We did compton scattering in the lecture and I put the notation we used for the process in an attachment, together with the case at hand in another notation.

It seems that by putting ##k \rightarrow k_1, \,\,\ q \rightarrow p_2\,\,\,\ q' \rightarrow p_1## I can get agreement between the two formulas for the unpolarised transition probability. The middle condition here I don't understand. Even though the photon with momentum q is in the initial state in compton scattering is it simply ok to put it to a photon of momentum ##p_2## in the final state of diphoton production?
Thanks!
 
Attachments
  • Two Feynman diagrams: (a) electron line k1 and k2 meeting at a vertex with photon lines p1 and p2 outgoing; (b) electron line k with photon q' outgoing, and photon q incoming with electron k' outgoing.
    diphoton1.png
    1.5 KB · Views: 717