Denton
- 120
- 0
What is the theory to explain how it still manages to survive.
The discussion revolves around the concept of electron survival at absolute zero (0K), exploring the implications of quantum mechanics, zero-point energy, and the conditions under which electrons can cease to exist. Participants examine theoretical aspects, definitions, and the behavior of particles at low temperatures.
Participants express differing views on the implications of zero-point energy, the nature of motion at 0K, and the conditions for electron disappearance. The discussion remains unresolved with multiple competing views present.
There are limitations regarding the assumptions made about definitions of survival, the implications of zero-point energy, and the conditions under which electrons can cease to exist. These aspects are not fully explored or agreed upon.
Do you perhaps mean that at 0K the atom's electrons should stop moving?Denton said:What is the theory to explain how it still manages to survive.
Tachyonie said:I know almost nothing about quantum physics but as far as I heard, there is always certian amount of minimum energy in system also called zero-point energy. You cannot have less than that amount of energy (Something to do with Planck scale). So Electron, nor any other particle can ever reach absolute 0k and therefore there is no problem with the electron survival.
Tachyon.
f95toli said:Not quite, due to the zero-point energy particles will move even at 0K.
(Although this motion will be very small).
Remember that there is no fundamental "equivalence" between motion and thermodynamic temperature, it is just that they happen to be related for e.g. a classical gas.
Riogho said:Even at 0k everything still moves.
Why?
Because if it didn't we'd know it's position and momentum, which is a no-no.
jackle said:As I recall, particles like electrons always survive unless there is a suitable reaction
they can undergo that allows them to disappear. This limits their options. Getting rid of their energy is just one problem they have.
Energy and momentum have to be conserved. Electrons have a rest mass, so even if they could stop moving they would have to get rid of the energy tied up in their rest mass before they could be allowed to leave. Momentum conservation normally means they have to hand over their momentum to another particle before they are allowed to go on holiday. There is also this thing called CPT symmetry, which lays down some rules about when they are allowed disappear.
My understanding is that electrons tend to survive pretty well. They only seem to be allowed to get out of their responsibilities by meeting up with positrons or getting promoted to being a muon or something like that. This is very rare, they can't just pop out of existence when they are running low on energy.