Examining Ductility of Al-Cu Alloy: Brittle vs Copper & Aluminum

  • Thread starter Thread starter tanky322
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Alloy Strength
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion examines the ductility of an Al-Cu alloy, specifically addressing its brittle nature compared to pure copper and aluminum. Participants explore the underlying reasons for this brittleness, including the effects of alloy composition and microstructural characteristics.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • Andrew notes that the Al-Cu alloy is hypoeutectic and suggests that brittleness may arise from rapid solidification at the eutectic point, potentially leading to fewer grain boundaries that could impede dislocation movement.
  • Another participant challenges Andrew's reasoning by stating that easy dislocation movement is typically associated with ductility, not brittleness, and questions how precipitates in the alloy might affect dislocation motion.
  • Andrew later cites a source indicating that the brittle nature of the Al-Cu alloy is due to its classification as an intermetallic compound, which possesses characteristics of both metals and ceramics, leading to a non-ordered atomic structure and numerous grain boundaries that hinder dislocation movement.
  • A participant acknowledges the relationship between strengthening a metal and increased brittleness, suggesting a trade-off in mechanical properties.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the mechanisms contributing to the brittleness of the Al-Cu alloy, with no consensus reached on the primary factors involved.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention various assumptions about the solidification process, the role of precipitates, and the nature of intermetallic compounds, but these aspects remain unresolved and are subject to further exploration.

tanky322
Messages
43
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Examine the ductility of the Al-Cu alloy. Note how brittle the mixture is- most unlike copper or aluminum-Why?


2. Relevant Information
The alloy was a 50-50 mix of Al and Cu heated to 700C and then poured into a mold, before the eutectic temp was reached the remaining molten metal was poured from the mold.


The Attempt at a Solution



I understand that the material is hypoeutectic(Eutectic is about 67%Al). I believe that at the eutectic point the material would be very brittle, I am under the impression that the material instantly solidifies. This in my opinion, might be wrong:confused:, would cause a minimum amount of grain boundaries which would not impede dislocation movement, thus making the material very brittle.

Now I am not really sure if that's right?


Thanks!

Andrew
 
Physics news on Phys.org
But easy dislocation movement is a characteristic of ductile, not brittle, materials. If strain energy can be easily stored in the form of plastic deformation, then it's difficult to fracture the material in a brittle way. So this argument isn't too convincing.

One thing an Al-Cu alloy contains that pure Cu and Al don't is precipitates of a different phase. How will these precipitates affect dislocation motion?
 
Hi mapes, thanks for responding.

I ended up figuring it out I think. This is what I ended up putting in my report for an answer. I got it from a DOE paper http://www1.eere.energy.gov/industry/imf/pdfs/intermetallics.pdf"

The brittle nature of the Al-Cu alloy can be attributed to the fact that it is an intermetallic compound. Intermetallics have unique characteristics of ceramics and metals, this allows them to have mechanical properties that place them in between the ductile nature of a metal and the harder and more brittle ceramics. At the atomic level intermetallics contain a mixed bonding type. They are both metallic and covalent/ionic, this causes them to have a non-ordered atomic structure. The abundance of grain boundaries created causes the material to have a very short plastic zone, this is due to the fact that the dislocations are impeded by the grain boundaries.

Thanks!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Any time. Yes, the flip side of strengthening a metal is increased brittleness.