Expectation of Continuous Random Variable [word problem]

5 replies · 3K views · last reply
izelkay
Messages
115
Reaction score
3

Homework Statement


Here's the problem with the solution provided:
Printed textbook page showing Example 2d: a worked solution deriving the time t* to depart for minimum expected cost, with the derivative of E[C_t(X)] and the result F(t*) = k/(k + c).


Homework Equations


Fundamental Theorem of Calculus (FToC)

The Attempt at a Solution


So I understand everything up to where I need to take the derivative of the integral(s).
Couple of things I know is that the derivative of the CDF, F(T) is the PDF, f(t). So naturally the integral of the PDF would be the CDF, right?

So for the first integral, ct∫f(x)dx [0,t]
I would need to use the product rule for this I think, so I'd have:

c∫f(x)dx [0,t] + ctf(t)

And since the integral of the PDF is the CDF, this would be:

cF(t) + ctf(t) right? That's what they have so far

For the second integral, -c∫xf(x)dx[0,t]

The derivative of this would just be
-ctf(t)

by the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus.

The third integral, k∫xf(x)dx [t,∞]

I believe I would need to switch the limits of integration for this to be able to differentiate using the FToC:

-k∫xf(x)dx [∞,t]

Then, differentiating this:

-ktf(t)

For the fourth integral I'm not sure what they did. I thought we just needed to switch the limits of integration again to get

kt∫f(x)dx [∞,t]

And then differentiate this to get

k∫f(x)dx [∞,t] + ktf(t)
=
kF(t) + ktf(t)

so in total, I'd have:

cF(t) + ctf(t) - ctf(t) - ktf(t) + kF(t) + ktf(t)

which matches what they have except for the last two terms. I'm not sure what's going on there, can someone explain?
 
Hm I'm looking at where I switched the limits of integration, and it doesn't really make sense to integrate something from infinity to t does it? Could that be the problem?
 
izelkay said:

Homework Statement


Here's the problem with the solution provided:
Handwritten-style typeset solution to Example 2d: piecewise cost C_t(X) equals c(t-X) if X ≤ t and k(X-t) if X ≥ t, followed by the expected-cost integrals, their derivative with respect to t, and the condition F(t*) = k/(k+c).


Homework Equations


Fundamental Theorem of Calculus (FToC)

The Attempt at a Solution


So I understand everything up to where I need to take the derivative of the integral(s).
Couple of things I know is that the derivative of the CDF, F(T) is the PDF, f(t). So naturally the integral of the PDF would be the CDF, right?

So for the first integral, ct∫f(x)dx [0,t]
I would need to use the product rule for this I think, so I'd have:

c∫f(x)dx [0,t] + ctf(t)

And since the integral of the PDF is the CDF, this would be:

cF(t) + ctf(t) right? That's what they have so far

For the second integral, -c∫xf(x)dx[0,t]

The derivative of this would just be
-ctf(t)

by the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus.

The third integral, k∫xf(x)dx [t,∞]

I believe I would need to switch the limits of integration for this to be able to differentiate using the FToC:

-k∫xf(x)dx [∞,t]

Then, differentiating this:

-ktf(t)

For the fourth integral I'm not sure what they did. I thought we just needed to switch the limits of integration again to get

kt∫f(x)dx [∞,t]

And then differentiate this to get

k∫f(x)dx [∞,t] + ktf(t)
=
kF(t) + ktf(t)

so in total, I'd have:

cF(t) + ctf(t) - ctf(t) - ktf(t) + kF(t) + ktf(t)

which matches what they have except for the last two terms. I'm not sure what's going on there, can someone explain?

The exerpt you quote has a very weird way of doing the derivative, and you are over-thinking the problem. In fact, using the general result
[tex]\frac{d}{dt} \int_{a(t)}^{b(t)} h(x,t) \, dx = h(b(t),t) b'(t) - h(a(t),t) a'(t) <br /> + \int_{a(t)}^{b(t)} \frac{\partial}{\partial t} h(x,t) \, dt[/tex]
we have
[tex]\frac{d}{dt} \int_0^t c(t-x) f(x)\, dx = c(t-x) f(x)|_{x=t} + \int_0^t \frac{\partial}{\partial t} c(t-x) f(x) \, dx\\<br /> = c \:0 \:f(t) + c \int_0^t f(x) \, dx = c F(t)[/tex]
and
[tex]\frac{d}{dt} \int_t^{\infty} k(x-t) f(x) \, dx = -k(x-t) f(x)|_{x=t} <br /> + \int_t^{\infty} \frac{\partial}{\partial t} k(x-t) f(x) \, dx \\<br /> = - k \: 0 \: f(t) - k \int_t^{\infty} f(t) \, dt.[/tex]
Since ##\int_t^{\infty} f(x) \, dx = 1 - F(t)##, we have
[tex]\frac{d}{dt} E C_t(X) = c F(t) - k[1-F(t)]= (c+k) F(t) - k[/tex]
 
Mm okay it makes sense with the formula you used, though I've never seen that formula before.