Exploring the Concept of Quantum Crystallization: Implications and Possibilities

  • Context: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter armandowww
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Quantum
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concept of quantum crystallization, particularly focusing on the properties and implications of quantum crystals, such as supersolidity and superfluidity, as well as potential applications in reducing friction in aerospace contexts. Participants explore theoretical aspects, experimental observations, and speculative engineering applications.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Experimental/applied

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants describe a quantum crystal as a state of Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) in solid form, characterized by macroscopic quantum phase coherence.
  • There are claims that quantum solids, like solid helium, may exhibit superfluidity, leading to counterintuitive behaviors such as the ability to "pass through" other solids.
  • One participant suggests the possibility of using He-4 as an atmospheric envelope to achieve frictionless flight, raising questions about practical applications.
  • Others argue against the feasibility of using He-4 for friction reduction in aerospace applications due to the extreme conditions required for solid helium and the challenges of maintaining low temperatures in atmospheric conditions.
  • Concerns are raised about the limitations of achieving superfluidity in solid helium, noting that only a small percentage may exhibit superflow under specific conditions.
  • Some participants discuss the engineering challenges related to high Mach numbers and the potential for using microstructures to enhance performance, while others caution about the physical limitations imposed by temperature and pressure.
  • A later reply questions the broader implications of Bose-Einstein condensation on materials, suggesting a curiosity about the potential to transform various materials into liquid states.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a mix of agreement and disagreement regarding the implications and feasibility of quantum crystallization applications. While some ideas are explored enthusiastically, others challenge the practicality and theoretical underpinnings, indicating that the discussion remains unresolved.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the dependence of quantum effects on temperature and pressure, as well as the unresolved nature of certain experimental observations related to solid helium. The discussion highlights the complexity of applying quantum phenomena in practical engineering scenarios.

armandowww
Messages
76
Reaction score
0
:cool: :smile: :cool: Can anybody tell me what is the meaning of a quantum crystall? I've heard it is referred to a lattice with vibrations over harmonic approximation. If so, what about the consequences?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
armandowww said:
:cool: :smile: :cool: Can anybody tell me what is the meaning of a quantum crystall? I've heard it is referred to a lattice with vibrations over harmonic approximation. If so, what about the consequences?

The meaning?
Generally, a 'quantum crystal' can be thought of as the very unusual state of a BEC in solid form, i.e., solid helium, for ex., characterized by quantum phase coherence macroscopically. I've heard it can be described otherwise.

The consequences are very counter intuitive ... a quantum solid is predicted to exhibit superfluidity, and apparently that is what happens. Some call it super solid; I refer to it as supersolidity. If it were possible to put a pure sample on a rotating turntable, the sample would not move :biggrin:
Is that what you had in mind?

Creator
 
Last edited:
Friction

Creator said:
The meaning?
Generally, a 'quantum crystal' can be thought of as the very unusual state of a BEC in solid form, i.e., solid helium, for ex., characterized by quantum phase coherence macroscopically. I've heard it can be described otherwise.

The consequences are very counter intuitive ... a quantum solid is predicted to exhibit superfluidity, and apparently that is what happens. Some call it super solid; I refer to it as supersolidity. If it were possible to put a pure sample on a rotating turntable, the sample would not move :biggrin:
Is that what you had in mind?

Creator
Is that because it has no friction? Also is solid gas possible, sorry but I'm not too skilled in this area?
 
Imop45 said:
Is that because it has no friction?

It is a purely quantum effect, and, yes, one result is that the quantum fluid (or in this case the quantum solid, say He-4) experiences no 'friction' with the 'container'. However, the implications are more far reaching.

Recent solid He-4 experiments apparently reveal that this quantum effect allows solid He-4 to "pass through" another solid while both are in solid phase.
Isn't QM interesting. :wink:

Creator :biggrin:
 
Could we use the He-4 as an Atmospheric Envelope leaking through the pores of a Space Craft/Air Craft Skin to allow the vehicles to experience Zero Friction, If the He-4 oozes from the Skin pores wouldn't it allow for this? Frictionless Flight.
 
Intuitive said:
Could we use the He-4 as an Atmospheric Envelope leaking through the pores of a Space Craft/Air Craft Skin to allow the vehicles to experience Zero Friction, If the He-4 oozes from the Skin pores wouldn't it allow for this? Frictionless Flight.
No it wouldn't.

I would strongly recommend anyone that wishes to talk about supersolidity, please, first read the paper by Kim and Chan...please.

http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v427/n6971/abs/nature02220.html
 
Intuitive said:
Could we use the He-4 as an Atmospheric Envelope leaking through the pores of a Space Craft/Air Craft Skin to allow the vehicles to experience Zero Friction, If the He-4 oozes from the Skin pores wouldn't it allow for this? Frictionless Flight.

Nice idea, Intuitive; but as is commonly the case with cryogenic quantum effects, the practical applications remain distant.
In this case...
Solid He-4 melting point is around 0.2 *Kelvin, and requires high pressure to remain solid.

Nevertheless, at such low temp. and high pressure the solid 'superflow' effect remains real. However, it is not 100% as in the case of liquid helium superfluidity; rather only a small percentage of the solid becomes superflow below the melting point, (and if I'm not mistaken the % has a temp./pressure dependency).

Creator
 
Last edited:
Creator said:
Nice idea, Intuitive; but as is commonly the case with cryogenic quantum effects, the practical applications remain distant.
In this case...
Solid He-4 melting point is around 0.2 *Kelvin, and requires high pressure to remain solid.

Nevertheless, at such low temp. and high pressure the solid 'superflow' effect remains real. However, it is not 100% as in the case of liquid helium superfluidity; rather only a small percentage of the solid becomes superflow below the melting point, (and if I'm not mistaken the % has a temp./pressure dependency).

Creator

Very informative, Thanks.

Would you happen to know what the Atmospheric Pressure of Air is that is entering into an Air intake Ram at Mach 10?

From the link that Gokul43201 gave me to read inwhich I spent a couple of hours visiting links from that link as well and some others, it still looks like there is some engineering hope by using the vehicles own energy and areodynamics to give us what we need for the He-4 transition to take place couldn't it if we're dealing with high Mach numbers to play with?

Just trying to work out some Engineering details for more troubleshooting questions.

Something like this that uses micro Skin Riffles with Capularies exposed to high Mach Pressures.
 

Attachments

  • H4.gif
    H4.gif
    5.2 KB · Views: 624
Last edited:
Intuitive said:
Very informative, Thanks.

...it still looks like there is some engineering hope by using the vehicles own energy and areodynamics to give us what we need for the He-4 transition to take place couldn't it if we're dealing with high Mach numbers to play with?

.

I still don't think so :rolleyes: for the same reasons I gave before. For example, how are you going to keep the temperature below 0.2*K while it is exposed to the atmosphere? I've seen engineers who appear to work miracles, but they still have to stay within the confines of physical law.:biggrin:

If you're looking for reduction in friction or drag through a medium you may want to try something akin to super-cavitation that has recently been used to increase torpedo underwater velocities to several hundred mph.
Microscopic bubbles are released along the laminar flow of the surface of the structure as it moves through the medium.

BTW; front surface pressure scales as the square of the velocity; (so, for ex., the force on a surface from a head on 200 mph wind is 4 times that of a 100 mph velocity.)

However, I don't want to high jack the OP's original intent.

More details of Moses Chan's He-4 work via torsional oscillations is found in Science, vol 305, p.1941, 2004.

Creator:biggrin:
 
Last edited:
  • #10
So does this BOSE-Einstein condensation thing, mean that wood and all materials can be turned into let's say, liquid?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K