Exponential revision question I can't work out?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a problem in calculus involving the manipulation of an equation to isolate the variable "t". The original equation presented is "i=12.5(1-e^-t/cr)", and the goal is to make "t" the subject. Participants are exploring the steps necessary to transpose the equation correctly, particularly focusing on the use of natural logarithms.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the need to isolate the exponential term before applying logarithms. There is confusion about how to correctly manipulate the equation, particularly regarding the placement of the constant "1" and the implications of moving terms across the equation. Some participants suggest various interpretations of the equation's structure, leading to questions about the correct approach to transposition.

Discussion Status

The discussion is ongoing, with participants providing hints and guidance on how to proceed with the algebraic manipulation. There is a recognition of the need to clarify the steps involved in removing the constant from the right side of the equation. Multiple interpretations of the equation are being explored, and participants are actively questioning each other's reasoning without reaching a consensus.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the original equation's structure may lead to different interpretations, which complicates the transposition process. There is also mention of the variables involved, such as resistance and capacitance, which may affect the context of the problem.

Ramjam
Messages
21
Reaction score
0
< Mentor Note -- Thread moved from the Calculus forum to HH/Calculus >[/color]

Hey everyone, I've started my new course and have been given revision and tutorial questions to do at home, this question has been bugging me for days now! I need to make "t" the subject to allow me to progress into the solution further.

Make t the subject in " i=12.5(1-e^-t/cr) "
I know that i need to use natural logs (ln) however i cannot seem to transpose the equation correctly. Could you please help me transpose this.

Thanks
Ramjam

p.s forgot to add my working so far, DUH!
ive transposed it to this form so far
i/12.5 = 1 - e ^-t/cr

this is where the logs come in and i have trouble, I am not sure what to do next?!?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Before taking logs, you must make e^{-t/cr} the subject.
 
Ramjam said:
< Mentor Note -- Thread moved from the Calculus forum to HH/Calculus >

Hey everyone, I've started my new course and have been given revision and tutorial questions to do at home, this question has been bugging me for days now! I need to make "t" the subject to allow me to progress into the solution further.

Make t the subject in " i=12.5(1-e^-t/cr) "
This is very unclear.
The quantity in parentheses could be any of the following:
##1 - \frac{e^{-t}}{cr}##
##1 - \frac{e^{-t}}{c}r##
##1 - e^{-t/c * r}##
Ramjam said:
I know that i need to use natural logs (ln) however i cannot seem to transpose the equation correctly. Could you please help me transpose this.

Thanks
Ramjam

p.s forgot to add my working so far, DUH!
ive transposed it to this form so far
i/12.5 = 1 - e ^-t/cr

this is where the logs come in and i have trouble, I am not sure what to do next?!?
No, logs don't come in yet. You still have that 1 on the right side.
 
How do I go about removing the one on the right hand side, is it correct for me to move it to the left hand side, leaving e^-t/cr on the right?
 
Mark44 said:
This is very unclear.
The quantity in parentheses could be any of the following:
##1 - \frac{e^{-t}}{cr}##
##1 - \frac{e^{-t}}{c}r##
##1 - e^{-t/c * r}##
No, logs don't come in yet. You still have that 1 on the right side.

He might even mean ##\frac{1-e^{-t}}{cr}##. For some unknown reason, he refuses to deal with your question.
 
My lecturer hinted that the 1 should be moved leaving e^t/cr on the right, however unsure how to transpose it to that
 
< Mentor Note -- Thread moved from the Calculus forum to HH/Calculus >
I moved this to the pre-calc forum since the issue is apparently about basic algebra.
 
Ramjam said:
My lecturer hinted that the 1 should be moved leaving e^t/cr on the right, however unsure how to transpose it to that
Please address the question I asked in post #3.
 
Mark44 said:
Please address the question I asked in post #3.
1-e-t/cr sorry my phone cut your post so I didn't understand what you meant
 
  • #10
You have
Ramjam said:
i/12.5 = 1 - e -t/cr
What can you do to both sides of this equation so that the 1 on the right side is gone? Possible choices are to add the same number toboth sides, subtract the same number from both sides, multiply both sides by the same nonzero number, or divide both sides by the same nonzero number.
 
  • #11
If I was to add 1 to both sides e.g i/12.5 + 1 = 1-1e-t/cr is this acceptable? As then the one can be removed from the right ?
 
  • #12
Ramjam said:
If I was to add 1 to both sides e.g i/12.5 + 1 = 1-1e-t/cr is this acceptable?
No, plus it's wrong.
i/12.5 = 1 - e-t/cr

If you add 1 to both sides, you get
i/12.5 + 1 = 1 - e-t/cr + 1 = 2 - e-t/cr
So that's no help at all.

Note that 1e-t/cr is exactly the same as e-t/cr, so there's no point in writing a coefficient of 1 here.

Ramjam said:
As then the one can be removed from the right ?
Nope.
 
  • #13
Could you possibly take me through step by step how to remove 1 from the right leaving e-t/cr so that I can see how it's done, as confusing my self now

Ramjam
 
  • #14
Ramjam said:
Could you possibly take me through step by step how to remove 1 from the right leaving e-t/cr so that I can see how it's done, as confusing my self now
There is no "step by step" here - this is not a complicated process. Earlier in this thread you said,
Ramjam said:
If I was to add 1 to both sides e.g i/12.5 + 1 = 1-1e-t/cr is this acceptable?
You added 1 to the left side, but you didn't add 1 to the right side. Whatever you do to one side of the equation, you have to do the same to the other side.

If you have i/12.5 = 1 - e-t/cr, what can you add to the 1 on the right side to get rid of it? In other words, what + 1 = 0?
 
  • #15
Mark44 said:
There is no "step by step" here - this is not a complicated process. Earlier in this thread you said,
You added 1 to the left side, but you didn't add 1 to the right side. Whatever you do to one side of the equation, you have to do the same to the other side.

If you have i/12.5 = 1 - e-t/cr, what can you add to the 1 on the right side to get rid of it? In other words, what + 1 = 0?

Okay so adding -1 to both sides i/12.5 -1 = 1-e-t/cr -1
which when becomes i/12.5 -1 = -e-t/cr

isnt the minus infront the the "e" become an issue? as you can log "-e"

Thankyou for your help on the matter
 
  • #16
You can still multiply both sides by the same factor...
(and you should try those basic steps yourself)
 
  • #17
Ramjam said:
Okay so adding -1 to both sides i/12.5 -1 = 1-e-t/cr -1
which when becomes i/12.5 -1 = -e-t/cr
Yes.
Ramjam said:
isnt the minus infront the the "e" become an issue? as you can log "-e"
So what can you do to get rid of the minus sign? Remember to do the same thing to both sides of the equation.
 
  • #18
Mark44 said:
Yes.
So what can you do to get rid of the minus sign? Remember to do the same thing to both sides of the equation.
Umm... I am not actually to sure? :/
 
  • #19
Ramjam said:
Umm... I am not actually to sure? :/
Then try different things. At least one of them will work.
 
  • #20
mfb said:
Then try different things. At least one of them will work.
Well I've been trying things for the past half hour with no luck, I am not seeing how i can multiply both sides to remove the minus from the "e"
 
  • #21
Ramjam said:
Well I've been trying things for the past half hour with no luck
Then show your work please.

What could you multiply a negative number with to get a positive number?
 
  • #22
mfb said:
Then show your work please.

What could you multiply a negative number with to get a positive number?
By multiplying -1 to let's say -1 you get 1, therefore I can see that by multiplying -1 to my equation will result in the right hand side becoming
e-t/cr

However if i was then to multiply the other side as required i don't see what i will get?
 
  • #23
Ramjam said:
By multiplying -1 to let's say -1 you get 1, therefore I can see that by multiplying -1 to my equation will result in the right hand side becoming
e-t/cr

However if i was then to multiply the other side as required i don't see what i will get?
Show us what you get when you multiply the left side by -1.
 
  • #24
Mark44 said:
Show us what you get when you multiply the left side by -1.
- l/12.5 -1 ?
 
  • #25
Ramjam said:
- l/12.5 -1 ?
OK, what's the complete equation?
 
  • #26
- l/12.5-1=e-t/cr

However doesn't this cause another issue with now there's a negative on the left preventing me logging?
 
  • #27
Ramjam said:
- l/12.5-1=e-t/cr

However doesn't this cause another issue with now there's a negative on the left preventing me logging?
i is a variable - it could be positive or negative.

In your original equation, which was ##i = 25(1 - e^{-t/(cr)})##, if e-t/(cr) > 1, then i will be negative.
 
  • #28
Mark44 said:
i is a variable - it could be positive or negative.

In your original equation, which was ##i = 25(1 - e^{-t/(cr)})##, if e-t/(cr) > 1, then i will be negative.
The original equation was i = 12.5(1-e-t/cr the reason it became i over 12.5 was because i divided 12.5 on both sides to remove it from the right.
 
  • #29
Heres the full question that i should of probably started with (my mistake) The current, i, flowing in a capacitor at time, t, is given by i = 12.5(1-e-t/cr where resistance, R, is 30KΩ and capacitance, C, is 20μF Determine the time for the current to reach 10 amperes?

So i know that by dividing both sides by 12.5 allows me to get i/12.5 = 1-e-t/cr and then by subtracting -1 from both sides gives me i/12.5 -1 = -e-t/cr, then by multiplying by -1 give me - i/12.5 = e-t/cr from this point on can i log both sides as the minus on the left is there?
 
  • #30
Ramjam said:
Heres the full question that i should of probably started with (my mistake) The current, i, flowing in a capacitor at time, t, is given by i = 12.5(1-e-t/cr where resistance, R, is 30KΩ and capacitance, C, is 20μF Determine the time for the current to reach 10 amperes?
Yes, you should have given us the complete problem statement. With the i, C and R, I figured this was a problem about an RC circuit.
Ramjam said:
So i know that by dividing both sides by 12.5 allows me to get i/12.5 = 1-e-t/cr and then by subtracting -1 from both sides gives me i/12.5 -1 = -e-t/cr, then by multiplying by -1 give me - i/12.5 = e-t/cr
No. Before you multiplied, the left side was i/12.5 - 1. After you multiplied by -1, what happened to the -1?
Ramjam said:
from this point on can i log both sides as the minus on the left is there?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
5K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
16K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K