Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the position space representation of the Feynman propagator on a cylindrical geometry, specifically for a scalar quantum field. Participants explore the differences between momentum space and position space representations, and the implications of periodic boundary conditions.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Mathematical reasoning
Main Points Raised
- One participant inquires about the position space representation of the Feynman propagator on the cylinder, noting that while the momentum space representation resembles that of Minkowski 2D space, the position space representation differs due to the integrals over momenta being replaced by sums.
- Another participant suggests consulting Kleinert's book on Path Integrals, which may contain relevant information regarding curvilinear coordinates.
- A participant expresses that Kleinert's book does not address the needs for fields, specifically seeking the Feynman propagator for a scalar quantum field on the cylinder.
- One participant cites a paper by Grosche that provides the propagator in cylindrical coordinates and suggests adding a specific integral to the expression, while acknowledging the complexity of the resulting expression.
- Another participant proposes that searching for screened Coulomb interactions with periodic boundary conditions might yield useful insights, referencing the Ewald summation literature as a potential source.
- A participant clarifies the distinction between quantum mechanics and field theory in cylindrical coordinates, emphasizing the need for an explicit expression involving a sum and integral that represents the inverse Fourier transform of the Feynman propagator in momentum space.
- One participant questions the relevance of the screened Coulomb interaction to the current problem, seeking clarification on whether any notes include the necessary sum/integral.
- Another participant acknowledges the misunderstanding regarding the context of cylindrical coordinates and expresses that their previous attachment is not applicable.
- One participant references notes from MIT OCW that may contain the desired expression, indicating a specific formula related to the propagator.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on the position space representation of the Feynman propagator on the cylinder. Multiple competing views and suggestions are presented, but no definitive solution is established.
Contextual Notes
Participants express uncertainty regarding the applicability of various references and the complexity of the expressions involved. There is a lack of clarity on how the different representations relate to the specific requirements of the problem at hand.