MHB Field extensions and roots of polynomials

mathgirl1
Messages
21
Reaction score
0
Let F be a field extension of Q (the rationals) with [F:Q] = 24. Prove that the polynomial $$x^5+2x^4-16x^3+6x-10$$ has no roots in F.

Proof:

Let $$a$$ be a root of $$x^5+2x^4-16x^3+6x-10$$. Since the polynomial has degree 5 by theorem we know that $$[Q(a):Q]=5$$. If $$a \in F$$ and $$[F:Q]=24$$ then by theorem we have that $$ [F:Q] = [F:Q(a)][Q(a):Q] \implies 24 = [F:Q(a)] 5 $$ which means that $$ [F:Q(a)] $$can not be an integer which would imply that the polynomial has not roots in F.

I think this is pretty accurate but also seems kind of too simple. Can someone please confirm whether this is correct or give advice to proceed correctly?

Thank you!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hi mathgirl,

It's not true that since the polynomial has degree $5$, then $[\Bbb Q(a):\Bbb Q] = 5$ as a direct consequence. What you've missed in your argument is that the polynonmial is irreducible over $\Bbb Q$. Since the polynomial is irreducible of degree $5$, then $[\Bbb Q(a): \Bbb Q] = 5$. The irreducibility may be proven by applying Eisenstein's criterion for the prime $p = 2$.
 
Ah ha! Yes! Thank you very much! I knew I was missing something. Much appreciated!
 
Back
Top