Find the length of largest square

17 replies · 3K views · last reply
Kaustubh sri
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
Find the length of largest square accommodated in a right angled triangle whose perpendicular length is 16 m and base's length is 8 m.

My attempt
I have tried a lot to find the length but every time it comes in fraction , i think that the figure i have made is wrong
. The answer I am getting is 16/3,could anybody tell me whether i am right or wrong.
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn right triangle ABC with vertical side AB labelled 16m and horizontal base BC labelled 8m, with a square BDEF inscribed at the right-angle corner, each side labelled x.
    1410400288356.jpg
    9.6 KB · Views: 594
Kaustubh sri said:
Find the length of largest square accommodated in a right angled triangle whose perpendicular length is 16 m and base's length is 8 m.

My attempt
I have tried a lot to find the length but every time it comes in fraction , i think that the figure i have made is wrong
. The answer I am getting is 16/3,could anybody tell me whether i am right or wrong.

Seems right. How you are getting the answer is maybe more interesting than just the diagram.
 
Dick said:
Seems right. How you are getting the answer is maybe more interesting than just the diagram.

I have only applied the concept of similarity in which triangle ADE Is similar to Triangle ABC and thus from the photo below u could find the value of x.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten working on paper, rotated sideways: triangle ADE similar to triangle ABC, so AD/AB = DE/BC = AE/AC, written as a chain of equal ratios.
    1410402506199.jpg
    18.4 KB · Views: 567
Kaustubh sri said:
I have only applied the concept of similarity in which triangle ADE Is similar to Triangle ABC and thus from the photo below u could find the value of x.

Sounds right. I think 16/3 is correct.
 
Dick said:
Sounds right. I think 16/3 is correct.

I know from this way the answer is correct but if the squre in the triangle could be accommodated in any other way then,
 
Kaustubh sri said:
I know from this way the answer is correct but if the squre in the triangle could be accommodated in any other way then,

You are right to consider there may be another way to fit a square in the triangle.
First, suppose the square does not touch all sides of the triangle. Show that there must be a larger square.
Now suppose no side of the square is parallel to a side of the triangle. Is there a small change that could be made to increase the size of the square?
And so on, until you only have two cases to consider.
 
haruspex said:
You are right to consider there may be another way to fit a square in the triangle.
First, suppose the square does not touch all sides of the triangle. Show that there must be a larger square.
Now suppose no side of the square is parallel to a side of the triangle. Is there a small change that could be made to increase the size of the square?
And so on, until you only have two cases to consider.

Suppose the square is in this case then
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn diagram of right triangle ABC with a right angle at B, and a square FGDE inscribed in it with F on AB, E on BC and G, D on the hypotenuse AC.
    1410447920536.jpg
    11.3 KB · Views: 543
Kaustubh sri said:
Suppose the square is in this case then

Quite so. It remains to compute the size of the square in that arrangement and see which is bigger.
 
My mind is not working in finding the length in this way , can u suggest how to find the length
 
Kaustubh sri said:
My mind is not working in finding the length in this way , can u suggest how to find the length

Going by your diagram, EF is parallel to AC and since the gradient of AC = -2, then let F cut the y-axis at y=a. Now you can find where E cuts the x-axis in terms of a, then you can find the length of EF, and so you just need to find an expression in terms of a for the parallel distance between EF and AC. What gradient would a line perpendicular to AC have?
 
Find similar triangles again. What is the ratio y/x comparing the small right triangle PQC with the big one, BAC? Also, x2+y2=a2. How are x and y related to a?

The yellow triangle is also similar to the big one. You can write an equation among the sides...
 
Attachments
  • Right triangle ABC with a square PQ inscribed at the right angle, labeled with sides x, y, 16-y, 8-x, side a, hypotenuse segment 8√5, and angle β at B.
    trigsquar.JPG
    8.8 KB · Views: 532
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
ehild said:
Find similar triangles again. What is the ratio y/x comparing the small right triangle PQC with the big one, BAC? Also, x2+y2=a2. How are x and y related to a?

The yellow triangle is also similar to the big one. You can write an equation among the sides...

Thanks sir ehild I got it , I was knowing about you from one of my friend #satvik pandey , you are great.Thanks man.
 
I tried this.

As ##\triangle ACB\sim \triangle QCP##


So ##\frac { 8 }{ x } =\frac { 8\sqrt { 5 } }{ a } ##


or ##\frac { 8 }{ x } =\frac { 8\sqrt { 5 } }{ { x }^{ 2 }+{ y }^{ 2 } } ##


or ##x\sqrt { 5\quad } ={ x }^{ 2 }+{ y }^{ 2 }##

But ##y=2x##

So ##x=\frac { 8 }{ \sqrt { 5 } } ##

but ##a=\sqrt { 5 } x##.

So ##a=8##

This is larger than 16/3.
Is this the answer of this question?
 
Satvik Pandey said:
I tried this.

As ##\triangle ACB\sim \triangle QCP##So ##\frac { 8 }{ x } =\frac { 8\sqrt { 5 } }{ a } ##or ##\frac { 8 }{ x } =\frac { 8\sqrt { 5 } }{ { x }^{ 2 }+{ y }^{ 2 } } ##

##a=\sqrt{x^2+y^2}## and y=2x, so your equation transforms to ##\frac { 8 }{ x } =\frac { 8\sqrt { 5 } }{ \sqrt{ x ^ 2 + y ^ 2 } }=\frac { 8\sqrt { 5 } }{ \sqrt{5 x^2 }}=\frac{8}{x}##:-p

ehild
 
ehild said:
##a=\sqrt{x^2+y^2}## and y=2x, so your equation transforms to ##\frac { 8 }{ x } =\frac { 8\sqrt { 5 } }{ \sqrt{ x ^ 2 + y ^ 2 } }=\frac { 8\sqrt { 5 } }{ \sqrt{5 x^2 }}=\frac{8}{x}##:-p

ehild
Yes I did a silly mistake.Sorry:-p
As ##\triangle ABC\sim \triangle PFB##

F is a point of intersection of red line passing through P and AB.

So ##\frac { 16 }{ a } =\frac { 8\sqrt { 5 } }{ 8-x } ##

or ##16-2x=\sqrt { 5 } a##

but ##a=\sqrt { 5 } x##

so ##x=\frac { 16 }{ 7 } ##

So ##a=\frac { 16\sqrt { 5 } }{ 7 } ##
 
Last edited:
Satvik Pandey said:
Yes I did a silly mistake.Sorry:-p
As ##\triangle ABC\sim \triangle PFB##

F is a point of intersection of red line passing through P and AB.

So ##\frac { 16 }{ a } =\frac { 8\sqrt { 5 } }{ 8-x } ##

or ##16-2x=\sqrt { 5 } a##

but ##a=\sqrt { 5 } x##

so ##x=\frac { 16 }{ 7 } ##

So ##a=\frac { 16\sqrt { 5 } }{ 7 } ##


It is correct now! :thumbs:

ehild
 
ehild said:
It is correct now! :thumbs:

ehild
Thank you ehild for helping me.:smile: