Find the Mistake in Calculating Volume by Integration

6 replies · 2K views · last reply
keewansadeq
Messages
12
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


I have the attached problem ,and Show my answer and solution,

My answer is 3.14*(15 -8ln4)
While book answer 3.14(15+8ln)
Handwritten solution on lined paper: sketch of the curve y = -1 + 4/x between x = 1 and x = 4, with the region under it shaded, then the volume integral pi times the integral of (1 + 16/x^2 ... ) written out, the antiderivative, and the evaluated result pi(15 - 8 ln 4), with a note that the book answer is pi(15 + 8 ln 4).

Can anyone point to the mistake I made?
 
Your work also looks good to me.
The one thing I noticed is the answer from the book would be right if you take the negative away from the 1.

I'm guessing the book has a typo.
 
keewansadeq said:
While book answer 3.14(15+8ln)
If this is actually the book's answer, it makes no sense without something following ln.
 
Thanks
Absolutely right, but draw the function, you will see that volume is almost as his answer(using geometry not integration),and that why I am confused.
 
keewansadeq said:
Thanks
Absolutely right, but draw the function, you will see that volume is almost as his answer(using geometry not integration),and that why I am confused.

If you think that the book's answer ##\pi (15+8 \ln(4))## is close to the correct answer you are very much mistaken. The correct answer is yours, except that the approximation ##\pi = 3.14## is way too crude---just leave it as symbolic ##\pi## until it comes time to evaluate the final answer numerically. Look at the following:
[tex]\begin{array}{rccc}<br /> \pi (15 - 8 \ln\,4 )& \doteq & 12.28251236 & \doteq & 12.3 \\<br /> \pi (15 + 8 \ln\,4 ) & \doteq & 81.96526726 & \doteq & 82.0 \\<br /> \pi 15 & \doteq & 47.12388981 & \doteq & 47.1<br /> \end{array}<br /> [/tex]
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Charles Link
you
Ray Vickson said:
If you think that the book's answer ##\pi (15+8 \ln(4))## is close to the correct answer you are very much mistaken. The correct answer is yours, except that the approximation ##\pi = 3.14## is way too crude---just leave it as symbolic ##\pi## until it comes time to evaluate the final answer numerically. Look at the following:
[tex]\begin{array}{rccc}<br /> \pi (15 - 8 \ln\,4 )& \doteq & 12.28251236 & \doteq & 12.3 \\<br /> \pi (15 + 8 \ln\,4 ) & \doteq & 81.96526726 & \doteq & 82.0 \\<br /> \pi 15 & \doteq & 47.12388981 & \doteq & 47.1<br /> \end{array}<br /> [/tex]
You are right his answer is not logical,

Thanks