MHB Find the total number of red and blue beads

  • Thread starter Thread starter anemone
  • Start date Start date
anemone
Gold Member
MHB
POTW Director
Messages
3,851
Reaction score
115
There are some red and blue beads.
The beads were packed into 2 containers.
At first, Container A contained 500 beads and $\dfrac{2}{5}$ of them were blue beads. Container B contained 300 beads and $\dfrac{1}{5}$ of them were blue.

Find the total number of red and blue beads that must be moved from Container A to Container B such that $\dfrac{3}{5}$ of the beads in Container A are red and $\dfrac{1}{4}$ of the beads in Container B are blue.

I am wondering if this problem can be solved without using any algebra method...
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
Hi anemone,

Are you sure the problem is correctly stated ?

As I read it, you should still end up with $\dfrac25$ blue beads in container A. As the proportion does not change, you must move $3$ red beads for every $2$ blue.

However, this can only decrease the proportion of blue beads in container B, and it cannot increase from $\dfrac15$ to $\dfrac14$.

Did I miss something ?
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
Initially, 60 of the 300 beads in container B are blue. After adding $5n$ beads, $2n$ of which are blue, the proportion will be $\dfrac{60+2n}{300+5n}$, which could increase towards a limit of $\dfrac25$ for large enough $n$.
 
castor28 said:
Hi anemone,

Are you sure the problem is correctly stated ?

Thanks for the reply, castor28! Yes, I checked again with the source from where I got the problem, there isn't any typo.

castor28 said:
As I read it, you should still end up with $\dfrac25$ blue beads in container A. As the proportion does not change, you must move $3$ red beads for every $2$ blue.

However, this can only decrease the proportion of blue beads in container B, and it cannot increase from $\dfrac15$ to $\dfrac14$.

Did I miss something ?
(Mmm) I actually don't see why not...(Crying)
 
The following method (without using algebra but the Singapore model method) works, by separating one part of fraction in container A into 5 equal subparts and one part of fraction in container B into 3 equal subparts, where each subpart represents 20 beads as shown below:

Before:
[TIKZ]
\coordinate[label=left: Container A] (A) at (0,5.3);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.3,5) rectangle (0.6,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.6,5) rectangle (0.9,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.9,5) rectangle (1.2,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (1.2,5) rectangle (1.5,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (1.5,5) rectangle (1.8,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (1.8,5) rectangle (2.1,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (2.1,5) rectangle (2.4,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (2.4,5) rectangle (2.7,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (2.7,5) rectangle (3,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (3,5) rectangle (3.3,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.3,5) rectangle (3.6,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.6,5) rectangle (3.9,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.9,5) rectangle (4.2,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (4.2,5) rectangle (4.5,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (4.5,5) rectangle (4.8,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (4.8,5) rectangle (5.1,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (5.1,5) rectangle (5.4,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (5.4,5) rectangle (5.7,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (5.7,5) rectangle (6,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (6,5) rectangle (6.3,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (6.3,5) rectangle (6.6,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (6.6,5) rectangle (6.9,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (6.9,5) rectangle (7.2,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (7.2,5) rectangle (7.5,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (7.5,5) rectangle (7.8,6);
\draw [very thick] (0.3,5) rectangle (1.8,6);
\draw [very thick] (1.8,5) rectangle (3.3,6);
\draw [very thick] (3.3,5) rectangle (4.8,6);
\draw [very thick] (4.8,5) rectangle (6.3,6);
\draw [very thick] (6.3,5) rectangle (7.8,6);
\coordinate[label=left: Container B] (B) at (0,5.-1);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.3,3.6) rectangle (0.6,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.6,3.6) rectangle (0.9,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.9,3.6) rectangle (1.2,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (1.2,3.6) rectangle (1.5,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (1.5,3.6) rectangle (1.8,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (1.8,3.6) rectangle (2.1,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (2.1,3.6) rectangle (2.4,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (2.4,3.6) rectangle (2.7,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (2.7,3.6) rectangle (3,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3,3.6) rectangle (3.3,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.3,3.6) rectangle (3.6,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.6,3.6) rectangle (3.9,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.9,3.6) rectangle (4.2,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (4.2,3.6) rectangle (4.5,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (4.5,3.6) rectangle (4.8,4.6);
\draw [very thick] (0.3,3.6) rectangle (1.2,4.6);
\draw [very thick] (1.2,3.6) rectangle (2.1,4.6);
\draw [very thick] (2.1,3.6) rectangle (3,4.6);
\draw [very thick] (3,3.6) rectangle (3.9,4.6);
\draw [very thick] (3.9,3.6) rectangle (4.8,4.6);
\draw [<->] (0.3,6.2) -- (0.6,6.2);
\node at (0.4,6.5) {20 beads};
[/TIKZ]

After:
[TIKZ]
\coordinate[label=left: Container A] (A) at (0,5.3);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.3,5) rectangle (0.6,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.6,5) rectangle (0.9,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.9,5) rectangle (1.2,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (1.2,5) rectangle (1.5,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (1.5,5) rectangle (1.8,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (1.8,5) rectangle (2.1,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (2.1,5) rectangle (2.4,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (2.4,5) rectangle (2.7,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (2.7,5) rectangle (3,6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (3,5) rectangle (3.3,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.3,5) rectangle (3.6,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.6,5) rectangle (3.9,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.9,5) rectangle (4.2,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (4.2,5) rectangle (4.5,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (4.5,5) rectangle (4.8,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (4.8,5) rectangle (5.1,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (5.1,5) rectangle (5.4,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (5.4,5) rectangle (5.7,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (5.7,5) rectangle (6,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (6,5) rectangle (6.3,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (6.3,5) rectangle (6.6,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (6.6,5) rectangle (6.9,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (6.9,5) rectangle (7.2,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (7.2,5) rectangle (7.5,6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (7.5,5) rectangle (7.8,6);
\draw [very thick] (0.3,5) rectangle (1.8,6);
\draw [very thick] (1.8,5) rectangle (3.3,6);
\draw [very thick] (3.3,5) rectangle (4.8,6);
\draw [very thick] (4.8,5) rectangle (6.3,6);
\draw [very thick] (6.3,5) rectangle (7.8,6);
\coordinate[label=left: Container B] (B) at (0,5.-1);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.3,3.6) rectangle (0.6,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.6,3.6) rectangle (0.9,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (0.9,3.6) rectangle (1.2,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (1.2,3.6) rectangle (1.5,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (1.5,3.6) rectangle (1.8,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (1.8,3.6) rectangle (2.1,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (2.1,3.6) rectangle (2.4,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (2.4,3.6) rectangle (2.7,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (2.7,3.6) rectangle (3,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3,3.6) rectangle (3.3,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.3,3.6) rectangle (3.6,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.6,3.6) rectangle (3.9,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (3.9,3.6) rectangle (4.2,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (4.2,3.6) rectangle (4.5,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (4.5,3.6) rectangle (4.8,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (4.8,3.6) rectangle (5.1,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=cyan, thin, draw=black] (5.1,3.6) rectangle (5.4,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (5.4,3.6) rectangle (5.7,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (5.7,3.6) rectangle (6,4.6);
\filldraw [fill=magenta, thin, draw=black] (6,3.6) rectangle (6.3,4.6);
\draw [very thick] (0.3,3.6) rectangle (1.2,4.6);
\draw [very thick] (1.2,3.6) rectangle (2.1,4.6);
\draw [very thick] (2.1,3.6) rectangle (3,4.6);
\draw [very thick] (3,3.6) rectangle (3.9,4.6);
\draw [very thick] (3.9,3.6) rectangle (4.8,4.6);
\draw [very thick, dotted] (4.8,3.6) rectangle (6.3,4.6);
\draw (2.7,5) --(3,6);
\draw (3,5) --(3.3,6);
\draw (6.9,5) --(7.2,6);
\draw (7.2,5) --(7.5,6);
\draw (7.5,5) --(7.8,6);
[/TIKZ]

As we can see, after moving 2 subparts of blue beads and 3 subparts of red beads from container A into container B, we get what we wanted in the end, $\dfrac{3}{5}$ of the beads in Container A are red and $\dfrac{1}{4}$ of the beads in Container B are blue.

Therefore, the total number of red and blue beads that must be moved from container A to container B is $5\times 20 =100$.
 
You're welcome, morgancol!

You're also encouraged to fire away with whatever math problems that you can't solve and wish to get some help at our forum! Just so you know, for problem involving fraction/ratio/percentage like this one, it can be solved using algebra or without algebra way. (Happy)
 
Insights auto threads is broken atm, so I'm manually creating these for new Insight articles. In Dirac’s Principles of Quantum Mechanics published in 1930 he introduced a “convenient notation” he referred to as a “delta function” which he treated as a continuum analog to the discrete Kronecker delta. The Kronecker delta is simply the indexed components of the identity operator in matrix algebra Source: https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/what-exactly-is-diracs-delta-function/ by...
Fermat's Last Theorem has long been one of the most famous mathematical problems, and is now one of the most famous theorems. It simply states that the equation $$ a^n+b^n=c^n $$ has no solutions with positive integers if ##n>2.## It was named after Pierre de Fermat (1607-1665). The problem itself stems from the book Arithmetica by Diophantus of Alexandria. It gained popularity because Fermat noted in his copy "Cubum autem in duos cubos, aut quadratoquadratum in duos quadratoquadratos, et...
I'm interested to know whether the equation $$1 = 2 - \frac{1}{2 - \frac{1}{2 - \cdots}}$$ is true or not. It can be shown easily that if the continued fraction converges, it cannot converge to anything else than 1. It seems that if the continued fraction converges, the convergence is very slow. The apparent slowness of the convergence makes it difficult to estimate the presence of true convergence numerically. At the moment I don't know whether this converges or not.
Back
Top