Finding i(t) and v_x in an RL circuit

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
SuperCat
Messages
26
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


Find i and v_x
Circuit schematic with a 2 H inductor on the left carrying current i downward, a 4 Ω resistor with voltage v_X across the top, a 1 Ω resistor in the middle branch, a dependent voltage source 2v_X below it, and a 4 Ω resistor on the right.

Given answer:
Printed answer line reading: Answer: 5e^(-4t) V, -20e^(-4t) V.
2. Homework Equations 3. The Attempt at a Solution
I have attempted the problem in two different manners, and I consistently reach a different answer. I would appreciate if someone would be willing to take the time to attempt the problem and confirm whether the provided solution is correct.

My answer:
i(t) = 5* e^(-5.6*t)
I have not attempted to solve for v_x yet, because I want to verify the first part of the answer.

Method 1: Apply KVL directly to the circuit
Typeset mesh-current equations: Loop 1 gives 13i1 - i2 + 2 di1/dt = 0; Loop 2 gives 5i2 - 9i1 = 0; then 56i1/5 + 2 di/dt = 0 and i(t) = 5e^(-5.6t).


Method 2: Find the equivalent resistance at the inductor terminals with a test voltage source.
I am not showing the work for this method, but I did it this way as well and received the same answer as my first attempt.

If my attempt is wrong, I really would appreciate some insight into where I went wrong.
 
I think your result looks better than theirs! Considering that they used the unit V for both voltage and current in their answer, I suspect that they have an editing issue with the answer key.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: SuperCat
Good point, I completely managed to overlook that! I just couldn't find this listed in the errata for my book so I blindly trusted it.