Finding mass from moment of inertia graph - inconsistency?

  • Thread starter marenubium
  • Start date
  • #1

Homework Statement


I have a disk that can rotate about an axis at a radial distance h from the center of the disk. I am given a graph showing the the rotational inertia I of the disk as a function of the distance h from the center of the disk out to the edge of the disk. From the graph (see attached picture) I can see that the ends of the graph are as follows: when h is zero (i.e. the axis is right on the center of the disk) I = 0.03 kg*m^2 and when h = 0.2m, I = 0.63 kg*m^2.

I am asked to determine the mass of the disk from these data.

Homework Equations



##I_p = I_{cm} + Md^2## (parallel axis theorem)
##I_{disk} = 1/2Mr^2## (the moment of inertia of a disk about its CM)

The Attempt at a Solution



Let point A be when h = 0, i.e. the axis is right on the CM. Let point B be when h = 0.2, i.e. on the edge of the disk. Applying the parallel axis theorem to both locations and given the values from the problem:

##I_B = I_{disk} + M(0.2)^2 = 0.63##
##I_A = I_{disk} + M(0)^2 = 0.03##

Subtracting the second equation from the first gives

##I_B - I_A = 0.63 - 0.03 = 0.60 = M[(0.2)^2 - 0^2]##

and so M = 15kg, which is the correct answer. But if I actually try to use this to recalculate the moment of inertia of the disk I get

##I_{disk} = 1/2Mr^2 = 1/2(15)(0.2^2) = 0.3 \not= I_A = 0.03##

and similarly I get the "wrong" answer for I_B using the parallel axis theorem. Is the problem just written poorly, or am I missing something really obvious here?

Thanks for any help... first time using Tex... hope I did okay.
 

Attachments

Answers and Replies

  • #2
TSny
Homework Helper
Gold Member
12,955
3,309
Hello, and welcome to PF!

You're thinking correctly. Note that the problem does not state that the disk is of uniform mass density. So, it might be a disk where Icm is not given by (1/2)Mr2.
 
  • #3
Oh, of course! I was completely on autopilot and made that assumption without thinking.

Thanks so much!
 
  • #4
lightgrav
Homework Helper
1,248
30
The problem was poorly written ... the disk's radius is only .067m, but they can spin it around an axis that's 3x that far from the center!
(expensive massless washer way bigger than the real disk?) . They should re-program the range of I_A values.
 
  • #5
I'm admittedly not sure where you are getting 0.067 m from. The problem statement implies that the edge of the disk from the center and thus the radius is 0.2 m.
 
  • #6
lightgrav
Homework Helper
1,248
30
oops, 0.0632 m ... from I_disk = 0.03 kgm^2 and mass 15kg.
 
  • #7
Right, but as TSny pointed out it's probably not reasonable here to assume the disk is uniform.
 
  • #8
lightgrav
Homework Helper
1,248
30
they called it a disk ... they're supposed to guide your model, not mis-guide it.
even a sphere would need radius less than about .1m !
 
  • #9
While I don't disagree, at the end of the day the bottom line is I made an assumption I shouldn't have, and that's what caused my problem on this problem, and I'll be more careful about my assumptions in the future.
 

Related Threads on Finding mass from moment of inertia graph - inconsistency?

Replies
17
Views
9K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
772
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
1K
Top