Discussion Overview
The discussion centers on finding the probability density function (pdf) of a transformed univariate random variable, specifically through the use of cumulative distribution functions (CDFs) and integration techniques. Participants explore the relationship between the pdf of the original variable and the transformed variable, addressing both theoretical and practical aspects of the transformation process.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Mathematical reasoning
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant questions the inclusion of the pdf of the original variable, ##f_X(x)##, in the integral for the CDF of the transformed variable, suggesting that the integral should be based solely on the transformation function, ##r(X)##.
- Another participant argues that the pdf, ##f_X(x)##, is necessary because it represents the probability density associated with the values of ##x## that satisfy the condition ##r(x) < y##, emphasizing the importance of integrating with respect to ##dx##.
- A third participant outlines a method for deriving the pdf of a transformed variable, ##Y=f(X)##, by first finding the CDF of ##Y## and then differentiating it with respect to ##y##, providing an example involving the chi-squared distribution.
- One participant acknowledges a potential oversight regarding the case where multiple ##x## values yield the same ##r(x)##, but maintains that the integral limits allow for the summation of associated densities.
- A later post corrects a reference to a website that provided a formula for the general normal distribution, clarifying that the standard normal distribution should be used with specific parameters.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express differing views on the role of the original pdf in the transformation process, with no consensus reached on the correct formulation of the integral for the CDF of the transformed variable. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best approach to derive the pdf of the transformed variable.
Contextual Notes
Participants note potential complications arising from multiple values of ##x## leading to the same transformed value, as well as the need for careful manipulation of the CDF based on the specific transformation function.