Finding the unknown cordinates of a point on a vector

  • Thread starter Thread starter EmilyHopkins
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Point Vector
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around finding the unknown coordinates of a point P on the line segment AB, defined by the position vectors of points A and B. Participants are tasked with expressing the distances AP and BP in terms of a variable t and determining the value of t, as well as the ratio of these distances.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the relationship between the vectors AP and PB, questioning how to express their parallelism algebraically. There are attempts to derive equations based on the cross product of these vectors. Some participants express uncertainty about finding the value of t and the implications of introducing an unknown variable k in their equations.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with various approaches being explored, including the use of cross products and the concept of vector parallelism. Participants are questioning assumptions and clarifying their understanding of the relationships between the vectors involved. There is no explicit consensus on a method or solution yet.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note potential sign mistakes in their expressions and the complexity introduced by additional variables. The discussion reflects a mix of attempts to clarify definitions and the setup of the problem, as well as the constraints of the homework context.

EmilyHopkins
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Relative to the origin O, the position vectors of two points A and B are (1,4) and (7,1) respectively. Give that the point P (t,t+1) is on AB find

1) AP and BP in terms of t

2) Find the value of t and hence the ratio AP:PBSolution:

1) AP= (-i - 4 j) + ti + (t+1)J = (t-1)i + (t-3)j
BP= -7i -j + ti + (t+1)j =(t-7)i + (t)j

2) I have no idea how to find t.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
EmilyHopkins said:
Relative to the origin O, the position vectors of two points A and B are (1,4) and (7,1) respectively. Give that the point P (t,t+1) is on AB find

1) AP and BP in terms of t

2) Find the value of t and hence the ratio AP:PBSolution:

1) AP= (-i - 4 j) + ti + (t+1)J = (1-t)i + (t-3)j
BP= -7i -j + ti + (t+1)j =(t-7)i + (t)j

2) I have no idea how to find t.

AP and PB are parallel vectors, since P is on AB, right? How do you express two vectors being parallel in algebra? BTW your expression for AP has a sign mistake.
 
Last edited:
Dick said:
AP and PB are parallel vectors, since P is on AB, right? How do you express two vectors being parallel in algebra? BTW your expression for AP has a sign mistake.

Well if AP and PB are parallel then their cross product is 0.

0 = AP X PB

0= ((t -1)i + (t-3)j) X (( T-7)i + tj)
0 = - (t-3)(t-7)k + (t-1)t k
0 = (3-t)(t-7) k + (t-1)tk
0= (3t -t^2-21+7t)k + (t-1)tk
0= (10t -t^2 -21)k + (t-1)tk
0= (10t -t^2 -21)k +(t^2 - t)k
0= (9t -21)k

9t-21=0
9t=21
t= 7/3
 
Last edited:
EmilyHopkins said:
Well if AP and PB are parallel then their cross product is 0.

That would be one way to go if you extend them to three dimensional vectors. It's also true that if they are parallel then they are multiples of each other. k*AP=PB for some constant k.
 
Dick said:
That would be one way to go if you extend them to three dimensional vectors. It's also true that if they are parallel then they are multiples of each other. k*AP=PB for some constant k.
Wouldn't that just introduce another unknown variable which would require us to have 2 equations in order to solve. I thought this route already but didn't bother going this way since I don't know the ratio, and hence the value of k.
 
Last edited:
EmilyHopkins said:
Well if AP and PB are parallel then their cross product is 0.

0 = AP X PB

0= ((t -1)i + (t-3)j) X (( T-7)i + j)
0 = - (t-3)(t-7)k + (t-1) k
0 = (3-t)(t-7) k + (t-1)k
0= (3t -t^2-21+7t)k + (t-1)k
0= (10t -t^2 -21)k + (t-1)k
0= (11t - t^2 -22)k

11t - t^2 -22 =0

a= -1, b= 11, c=--22

t = -11 ± (121 -4(-1)(-22))1/2/2(-1)

t= -1.72 or t= 12.7 ?

You are being pretty sloppy here. (t-7)i + (t)j turned into (( T-7)i + j). Something missing. If you do this right the t^2 will cancel.
 
EmilyHopkins said:
Wouldn't that just introduce another unknown variable which would require us to have 2 equations in order to solve. I thought this route already but didn't bother going this way since I don't know the ratio, and hence the value of k.

Once you split into components it WILL turn into two equations in the two unknowns t and k. It's about the same amount of work to do it this way as to solve the cross product equation.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K