Free radical stability: which temperature gives optimal stability?

7 replies · 3K views · last reply
Priyadarshini
Messages
191
Reaction score
4
Handwritten question asking which free radical is the most stable, with four options: CH2=CH-CH2 radical, benzyl radical on a benzene ring, (H3C)3C radical, and C2H5 radical.

Homework Statement

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


option 1: 1 degree C
option 2: 1 degree C
option 3: 3 degree C
option 4: 1 degree C

SO the answer should be option 3?
 
Is that the only stabilizing factor involved here?
Any polar effect involved?
PS- always thought saying tertiary or secondary carbon was a more universal naming system
 
Suraj M said:
Is that the only stabilizing factor involved here?
Any polar effect involved?
PS- always thought saying tertiary or secondary carbon was a more universal naming system
Why would there be a polar effect? Carbon and hydrogen have very similar electronegativities.
Yeah tertiary and primary are the universal terms, somehow this book doesn't refer to them as tertiary and primary carbons but as 1 degree, 2 degree and 3 degree carbons.
 
By polar effect, I am referring to mesmeric effect in this case
 
Suraj M said:
By polar effect, I am referring to mesmeric effect in this case
If the mesomeric effect is considered, then option 3 and 4 are ruled out. But I don't understand why I can't just see which carbon is tertiary and say that's the most stable.
 
I suggest thinking about what types of resonance give the greatest stability. Also consider drawing out resonance structures. Radical stability trends closely resemble carbocation trends (tertiary > secondary > primary). Think about where aromaticity fits into this trend.