Frozen in Time: Remarkable Mammoth and Rhino Discoveries in Alaska and Siberia

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jules18
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers on the discoveries of frozen mammoth and woolly rhinoceros specimens in Alaska and Siberia, exploring the implications of their preservation and the conditions under which they were found. Participants share various perspectives on the phenomenon of flash freezing and its relation to popular culture, as well as scientific insights into fossilization processes.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that the intact state of the mammoth and rhino specimens indicates they were flash frozen, with food still present in their mouths and stomachs.
  • Others challenge the comparison to the movie "The Day After Tomorrow," with one participant sarcastically referencing a fictional ice ray from a Batman movie.
  • One participant notes that many animals likely fell into icy bodies of water, leading to their rapid freezing, and mentions the role of sediment in their preservation.
  • Another participant highlights the lack of conclusive research regarding the conservation of these mammoths and points out the existence of various carbon dating results that show significant age differences among specimens.
  • There is mention of the Holocene Thermal Optimum affecting the preservation of mammoth remains, suggesting that environmental conditions played a role in their fossilization.
  • Participants express uncertainty about the overall understanding of the preservation processes, indicating that while some pieces of the puzzle are known, the complete picture remains unclear.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the implications of the findings or the validity of the flash freezing concept, with multiple competing views and ongoing uncertainty regarding the preservation processes of the specimens.

Contextual Notes

Some participants reference specific studies and articles that provide context for their claims, but there is no agreement on the interpretations of these findings. The discussion reflects a range of hypotheses and assumptions about the conditions leading to the preservation of the mammoths and rhinos.

Jules18
Messages
100
Reaction score
0
There have been remarkable discoveries of mammoth and wooly rhinoceros found in ice from Alaska and Siberia. Specimens with flesh, skin, and hair intact have been found. Some of these finds suggest that they were flash frozen, with food still in the mouth and stomach.

I found this in an article about fossilization and it kind of scared me - doesn't this remind you of the movie The Day After Tomorrow?
 
Earth sciences news on Phys.org
To think this has any relation to The Day After Tomorrow is ridiculous!
More than likely, the flash freezing of these fossils occurred due to Freeze's ice ray in Batman the movie.

But then again, I'm being sarcastic... so honestly, I'm not sure what to think on this subject.
 
Jules18 said:
I found this in an article about fossilization and it kind of scared me - doesn't this remind you of the movie The Day After Tomorrow?

How about providing the link to the article?
 
Many of the animals fell into icy lakes, rivers, etc... and ended up frozen. I will try to find more about how they froze, although Andre is out expert on these mammals.

You might like this article about the recent baby mammoth.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/07/070722113641.htm

This is what I believe you are referring to

Preserved frozen remains of woolly mammoths, with much soft tissue remaining, have been found in the northern parts of Siberia. This is a rare occurrence, essentially requiring the animal to have been buried rapidly in liquid or semi-solids such as silt, mud and icy water which then froze. This may have occurred in a number of ways. Mammoths may have been trapped in bogs or quicksands and either died of starvation or exposure, or drowning if they sank under the surface. The evidence of undigested food in the stomach and seed pods still in the mouth of many of the specimens suggests that neither starvation nor exposure are likely. The maturity of this ingested vegetation places the time period in autumn rather than in spring when flowers would be expected.[19] The animals may have fallen through ice into small ponds or potholes, entombing them. Many are certainly known to have been killed in rivers, perhaps through being swept away by river floods. In one location, by the Berelekh River in Yakutia in Siberia, more than 9,000 bones from at least 156 individual mammoths have been found in a single spot, apparently having been swept there by the current.[20]

[19]^ E. W. Pfizenmayer was one of the scientists who recovered and studied a mammoth that was found at the river Berezovka in the early 1900s. He wrote: “Its death must have occurred very quickly after its fall, for we found half-chewed food still in its mouth, between the back teeth and on its tongue, which was in good preservation. The food consisted of leaves and grasses, some of the latter carrying seeds. We could tell from these that the mammoth must have come to its miserable end in the autumn.” See Pfizenmayer, E. W. (1939). Siberian Man and Mammoth. London: Blackie and Son.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woolly_mammoth
 
Last edited:
Surprisingly enough, to date there has not been an elaborate conclusive research about the type of conservation of these mammoths -at least not that Dick Mol knowns of. And of course there are a lot of rural legends (as opposed to urban legends :smile: ).

Some facts,

- other detailed research about the conditions in Siberia in the past explicitely exclude any day-after-tomorrow-scenario's. See for instance Hubberten et al 2004.

- All mammoth mummies have different carbon datings with many thousend years differences. For instance about the baby mammoth that Evo linked to, we have a small paragraph in the book I translated, referring to it as well:

The best and most complete mammoth carcass ever discovered was on May 14, 2007. A reindeer herder named Yuri Khudi has found an entirely complete carcass of a baby mammoth, a female individual, near the Yuribei River on the Yamal Peninsula in arctic Siberia.

This carcass belongs to the collection of the Salekhard Museum in the sity of Salekhard now. It has been radiocarbon dated to 36690(+320,-280) BP ... ( Lab number GrA-35690).

Another famous mummy, the Jarkov Mammoth died a little over 20,000 years ago. But with a cataclysmic scenario, you would expect all mummies with the same date.

Contrary to belief, only relative small portions of the full grown animals were preserved, it the case of large adult animals it's mostly the head and limbs and indeed intestines. Other parts are rather putrified.

Also take note that these mummies in Siberia had to endure the Holocene Thermal Optimum, when the treeline advanced to the coastline of the Arctic ocean http://epic.awi.de/Publications/Mac2000c.pdf .

Highly recommended http://cio.eldoc.ub.rug.nl/FILES/root/2006/QuatIntMol2/2006QuatIntMol2.pdf

In short we know a lot more about pieces of the puzzle, but not how it fits together.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Jules18, that was a great question. I recall at one time having the same sort of unsettling feeling and was really glad to find out that entire herds were not flash frozen.
Thanks Andre, as always for the great links.
 
You're welcome Hypatia,

Actually it's a shame that the reality of the Siberian mammoth steppe of the late Pleistocene is so unknown that these flash frozen rural legends can linger on.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
8K