Future options as a Physics teacher

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the future career options for a Physics teacher, particularly focusing on the qualifications needed to teach at various educational levels, including high school and community college. Participants explore the implications of pursuing a Master of Arts in Teaching (MAT) in Physics and the potential for further academic advancement, such as obtaining a PhD.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant shares their background in business and experience teaching various science subjects, expressing a desire to teach high school physics and concerns about future career options.
  • Another participant notes that community colleges are increasingly hiring PhDs, suggesting that a MAT may not be sufficient for teaching positions at that level.
  • There is a discussion about the typical requirements for PhD programs in physics, with some participants suggesting that a BS in physics is generally preferred over a MAT.
  • Some participants mention the existence of PhD programs in Physics Education, which may be more accommodating to those with a teaching-focused background.
  • A participant involved in hiring at a community college emphasizes that qualifications for teaching physics vary by state and that an MAT may not meet the minimum qualifications in California.
  • Concerns are raised about the potential for boredom when teaching at the high school level without engaging with more challenging physics problems regularly.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the adequacy of a MAT for teaching at community colleges and the requirements for pursuing a PhD in physics. There is no consensus on the best path forward for the original poster regarding their qualifications and career aspirations.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight that hiring practices and qualifications can vary significantly by state and institution, particularly for community colleges and universities. The discussion reflects uncertainty about the implications of different degrees and the evolving landscape of academic hiring.

Strange design
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Hello all!
I was wondering if any of you Physics educators could help me realistically size up my future options as a Physics teacher.
Back story: After receiving my bachelor's degree in business management and simultaneously working in the business world for around 6 years, I became unhappy with my current career trajectory. I quit my job and volunteered to be a teacher overseas for a year. I was placed as a science teacher at a small school where I was basically the science dept. I taught, Physics, Chemistry, Biology, Earth Science, and Physical Science. It was a work load because I had to teach every science subject, but it was also really satisfying to be teaching across the science spectrum everyday. After a year, I really enjoyed it, particularly teaching physics, so I signed on for two more years. After 3 years of teaching there, it was time to come home. I want to continue to teach high-school, physics, so I am now enrolled and pursuing a master of arts in teaching physics degree. Since my undergrad is business, I am taking a large body of prerequisite physics courses for the program(nearly enough for a BS). After I complete the program I know I will be qualified to teach high-school physics, and the dept. head at the community college where I tutor math said the degree would qualify me to teach there as well.

I am wondering if I will ever have the option to teach at any level higher than that. I really enjoy working with Physics at a higher level, and am afraid that for one, I may become bored by teaching it at a high-school level after a while, and for two, that I will lose my ability to work with it at a higher level if I am not practicing it regularly, particularly the calculus.

If I did want to return to school down the road and pursue a Phd, would a MAT physics without a BS in Physics even be enough to do that?

For any high school Physics teachers out there, do you get bored not working with more challenging problems regularly?

Any wise words are appreciated.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Strange design said:
Hello all!
I was wondering if any of you Physics educators could help me realistically size up my future options as a Physics teacher.
Back story: After receiving my bachelor's degree in business management and simultaneously working in the business world for around 6 years, I became unhappy with my current career trajectory. I quit my job and volunteered to be a teacher overseas for a year. I was placed as a science teacher at a small school where I was basically the science dept. I taught, Physics, Chemistry, Biology, Earth Science, and Physical Science. It was a work load because I had to teach every science subject, but it was also really satisfying to be teaching across the science spectrum everyday. After a year, I really enjoyed it, particularly teaching physics, so I signed on for two more years. After 3 years of teaching there, it was time to come home. I want to continue to teach high-school, physics, so I am now enrolled and pursuing a master of arts in teaching physics degree. Since my undergrad is business, I am taking a large body of prerequisite physics courses for the program(nearly enough for a BS). After I complete the program I know I will be qualified to teach high-school physics, and the dept. head at the community college where I tutor math said the degree would qualify me to teach there as well.

I am wondering if I will ever have the option to teach at any level higher than that. I really enjoy working with Physics at a higher level, and am afraid that for one, I may become bored by teaching it at a high-school level after a while, and for two, that I will lose my ability to work with it at a higher level if I am not practicing it regularly, particularly the calculus.

If I did want to return to school down the road and pursue a Phd, would a MAT physics without a BS in Physics even be enough to do that?

For any high school Physics teachers out there, do you get bored not working with more challenging problems regularly?

Any wise words are appreciated.

In times gone by, Community College teachers often had Masters degrees. These days, there are lots and lots of PhDs looking for jobs. The glut of PhDs means that Community Colleges are hiring more PhDs. Most other universities will only hire PhDs, as well.

There may be some "typical" PhD programs that would be willing to take on someone with a MAT who is interested in pursuing a PhD in physics, but I suspect that most places want to see a BS in physics or a related area. Most programs want you in the lab doing experiments/theory for most of your tenure in grad school. There is not a lot of encouragement for you to spend time on learning to teach. With that said, some schools have PhD programs in Physics Education. I would look at schools with these Programs as being a better match for your background, but again, these places want you to do original research, albeit in education.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: ModusPwnd, Greg Bernhardt and Strange design
Quantum Defect said:
In times gone by, Community College teachers often had Masters degrees. These days, there are lots and lots of PhDs looking for jobs. The glut of PhDs means that Community Colleges are hiring more PhDs. Most other universities will only hire PhDs, as well.

There may be some "typical" PhD programs that would be willing to take on someone with a MAT who is interested in pursuing a PhD in physics, but I suspect that most places want to see a BS in physics or a related area. Most programs want you in the lab doing experiments/theory for most of your tenure in grad school. There is not a lot of encouragement for you to spend time on learning to teach. With that said, some schools have PhD programs in Physics Education. I would look at schools with these Programs as being a better match for your background, but again, these places want you to do original research, albeit in education.

That's a really good point. I hadn't thought about pursuing Physics education at a higher level. Thanks for the input.
 
Strange design said:
That's a really good point. I hadn't thought about pursuing Physics education at a higher level. Thanks for the input.

CU has a very strong program in this: http://www.colorado.edu/physics/EducationIssues/index.htm

I couldn't see what the pre-reqs were for people interested in entering the program.
 
I teach physics at a community college in California, and I've been involved in the hiring process for part-time and full-time faculty. To teach at a community college in California, you have to have certain minimum qualifications, called FSAs, which are enshrined in the ed code. I'd never heard of an MAT before this, but I'm pretty sure it doesn't meet the FSA for physics. That means you can't be hired in this state to teach physics at a community college, even at the adjunct level. Even if you had a regular master's degree, you would probably have a hard time finding anything but part-time work. For full-time positions, we usually have plenty of people with PhDs in the applicant pool.

If your goal is to teach at the community college level, a possible career path would be to get a job teaching high school, but meanwhile obtain a master's degree. Even if the master's degree didn't eventually lead to a community college job, it would increase your pay as a high school teacher.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Strange design
Strange design said:
the dept. head at the community college where I tutor math said the degree would qualify me to teach there as well.

As you can see from Ben's remarks, the qualifications required for community college teaching varies from state to state.

At 4-year colleges and universities, you pretty much have to have a Ph.D., except maybe for some adjunct (part-time) positions if they can't find a Ph.D. to fill the spot. But adjunct positions are probably used mainly for introductory courses anyway, not things like Griffiths-level E&M or QM.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Strange design

Similar threads

  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
4K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
5K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
4K