God's Plan vs Virgin Mary: An Interesting Music Night

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the reactions of fundamental Pentecostal families to the mention of the Virgin Mary during a music night, exploring themes of religious beliefs, cultural differences, and the perception of idolatry. The conversation touches on the implications of using certain religious terms in songs and the broader context of inter-denominational attitudes.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Meta-discussion

Main Points Raised

  • One participant notes that mentioning the Virgin Mary elicited strong negative reactions from Pentecostal attendees, contrasting this with their acceptance of violence in war as part of "God's plan."
  • Another participant suggests that the Virgin Mary is more associated with Catholicism, which may explain why Pentecostals are uncomfortable with her mention.
  • A participant humorously questions the term "Pentecostal," indicating a lack of familiarity with the denomination.
  • One participant speculates that Pentecostals might object to the word "virgin" due to its sexual connotations and expresses that they generally dislike Catholics for their practices regarding the Virgin Mary.
  • A personal anecdote is shared about a past relationship with a Pentecostal, highlighting cultural misunderstandings related to marriage expectations.
  • Another participant asserts that Pentecostals find the concept of the virgin birth absurd and provides a critical summary of their beliefs, which may not align with traditional Christian views.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the significance of the Virgin Mary in religious contexts, with some agreeing on the discomfort Pentecostals have regarding her mention, while others provide contrasting perspectives on the beliefs of Pentecostals and Catholics. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the underlying reasons for these attitudes.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include varying interpretations of religious beliefs, potential biases in personal anecdotes, and the lack of clarity on specific denominational doctrines that influence participants' views.

jobyts
Messages
226
Reaction score
60
Happened to go to a group of fundamental pentecostal families for a music night, where we spent the evening singing pop songs. We were singing a few devotional songs too, as expected. I randomly sang a virgin Mary devotional song, and everyone started looking at me as if I spoke some profanity. It was kind of interesting to watch how people are fine with killing each other in a war (since it's God's plan), but gets easily offended by mentioning virgin Mary's name.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I think that she is more of a catholic thing. They seem less bothered by hints of idolatry. I am not familiar enough to know if there as any particular reason pentecostals would have an issue with it.
 
What's a pentecostal? 5 costals?
 
jobyts said:
Happened to go to a group of fundamental pentecostal families for a music night, where we spent the evening singing pop songs. We were singing a few devotional songs too, as expected. I randomly sang a virgin Mary devotional song, and everyone started looking at me as if I spoke some profanity. It was kind of interesting to watch how people are fine with killing each other in a war (since it's God's plan), but gets easily offended by mentioning virgin Mary's name.

Yeah pentecostal people HATE catholics because they pray requesting virgin mary to 'forward' the message to god.
 
I think a pentecostal would have issue with the use of the word "virgin" spoken in a song. It emplies sex (or a lack of it). Also they really don't like catholics...

Now if it had been an old Christmas song instead of a pop song they probably would not have had any issues. Also did you just say "virgin Mary" or did you say something about her that could be taken as disrespectful.

I dated a pentecostal briefly. That was really interested.

I still remember to this day a botched conversation.

Her: "I don't know what I'm going to do if I'm not married by 25"

Me:(Without thinking)"I don't know what I'm going to do if I am married by 25."

I guess it worked out for her. She got married to an immature moron at the age of 19.
 
It was an old church song that I used to sing in my childhood. There was no disrespect involved.

Pentecostals believe virgin birth is absurd. They only believe in a cosmic Jewish Zombie who was his own father can make you live forever if you symbolically eat his flesh and telepathically tell him you accept him as your master, so he can remove an evil force from your soul that is present in humanity because a rib-woman was convinced by a talking snake to eat from a magical tree.
 
Sorry, this is going against our religious posting guidelines.

Closed.
 

Similar threads

The Strange Continuing Appeal of Charles Manson
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
4K