Helium balloon floating at air/helium boundary

In summary, during a review of the Archimedes Principle with AP students, a question about a helium-filled balloon in a jar of helium led to confusion over the correct answer. The book did not provide enough information about the mass of the balloon's structural material, leading to disagreement among the students. The correct answer is that the balloon would sink until it displaces a volume of air equal to the mass of the structural material, and would then float at the surface of the air inside the jar.
  • #1
pbbock
2
0
While reviewing the Archimedes Principle with my AP students using ConcepTest questions from the Wilson, Buffa, Lou text I came across an answer that I believe is incorrect. The question was the second question in a series of questions about a helium filled balloon.
The first question asked what would happen to a helium filled balloon in a jar of helium. The answer was that the balloon would sink to the bottom of the jar. OK, no problem. Then the next question says, "Now the jar is lifted off the table, but the jar remains inverted to keep the helium gas in the jar. What will happen to the balloon?" (From the choices I am assuming the lid is off the jar.)
These were the choices:
A) it floats at the top of the jar
B) it floats at the bottom of the jar, but still fully inside the jar
C) it floats below the bottom of the jar, sticking halfway out the bottom
D) it sinks down to the surface of the table

All of my students deduced that the helium filled balloon would still sink to the "bottom" (now the open end of the jar.) They disagreed, however, about where it would rest. I was very surprised when the answer provided was choice B. This was the explanation, "The balloon sinks in the helium gas (fluid #1), until it hits the surface of the air (fluid #2). Since the balloon floats in air, it will float on the surface of the air and therefore remain inside the jar, but at the bottom. "
This seems very wrong to me. It will only float on the surface of the air if there is a buoyant force. How can there be a buoyant force without some displacement of air? It doesn't seem philosophically different from an air-filled balloon floating on the surface of a liquid.
Can someone help me out here?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The reason this question is confusing is because the book doesn't give you enough information to correctly choose between B and C.

First I have to distinguish between two parts of the balloon: the helium filling the balloon and the actual structural part of the balloon--I'll call this the "plastic" part of the balloon.

The book leaves out a crucial bit of information: whether or not the plastic has mass. If the plastic had ZERO mass, the answer would be B. However, if, like a real balloon, there was a nonzero mass to the plastic part, the balloon would sink out of the jar until it displaces a volume of air with a mass equal to the mass of the plastic. (Of course this would not necessarily be exactly HALF way out of the jar, as C suggests.)

(Also we must assume that the plastic doesn't pressurize the baloon's helium giving it a higher density than the ambient helium.)
 
Last edited:
  • #3
I agree with you: the balloon must displace some air, or else it will continue to sink. A real-life balloon would probably displace a significant amount of air before it stops sinking.
 
  • #4
Jolb: I hear what you're saying about the mass, but a massless balloon wouldn't sink to the bottom of the jar in the first place.
 
  • #5
ideasrule said:
Jolb: I hear what you're saying about the mass, but a massless balloon wouldn't sink to the bottom of the jar in the first place.

Yes, you're right. A massless balloon would just float with neutral buoyancy through the helium.
 
  • #6
Thanks for your replies. The explanation for question one of this series did confirm that the helium-filled balloon would sink in helium. What was disappointing was that their explanation was simply that it had negative buoyancy. They didn't explain why. Like you all, my students and I assumed that it was because the balloon material itself had mass. That's why we were so confused on the second question. Again, thanks for your responses.
 

Related to Helium balloon floating at air/helium boundary

1. What causes helium balloons to float at the air/helium boundary?

Helium balloons float at the air/helium boundary because helium is less dense than air. This means that the upward force of the helium is greater than the downward force of gravity, causing the balloon to rise.

2. How does the size of the balloon affect its floating ability?

The size of the balloon does affect its floating ability. A larger balloon will have more helium and therefore more buoyancy, allowing it to float higher. However, if the balloon is too large, it may become too heavy and not be able to float at all.

3. Can helium balloons float indefinitely?

No, helium balloons cannot float indefinitely. Eventually, the helium will leak out of the balloon, causing it to become less buoyant and eventually fall to the ground.

4. Why do helium balloons sometimes deflate or fall to the ground?

As mentioned before, helium balloons will eventually deflate because helium is a very small molecule that can easily escape through the pores of the balloon material. Additionally, if the balloon is punctured or damaged in any way, the helium will escape and the balloon will fall to the ground.

5. Is it possible for a helium balloon to float too high?

Yes, it is possible for a helium balloon to float too high. As the balloon rises, the atmospheric pressure decreases which causes the balloon to expand. Eventually, the balloon will reach a point where it can no longer expand and will pop or burst.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
722
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
7K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
24
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
10K
Back
Top