High School Grades & College Expectations: Can I Become a Particle Physicist?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a high school student's concerns about their academic performance and aspirations to become a particle physicist. Participants explore the implications of high school grades on college admissions and future career paths in physics, while also addressing the student's uncertainty about their specific interests within the field of physics.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Meta-discussion

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that high school grades may not significantly impact future opportunities in physics once a student is accepted into a university.
  • Others argue that high school performance can reflect a student's future academic capabilities and work ethic.
  • A participant notes that while particle physics is interesting, students should explore various fields within physics to find their true interests.
  • Concerns are raised about the difficulty of physics as a subject, with some participants emphasizing that it can be challenging and sometimes tedious.
  • One participant shares their personal experience of overcoming similar academic struggles and achieving success in college, encouraging the original poster to pursue their interests despite current challenges.
  • Another participant questions the original poster's commitment to becoming a particle physicist, suggesting that a strong work ethic is necessary for success in the field.
  • There is a mention of the pressure associated with gaining admission to prestigious colleges, which some participants acknowledge can lead to increased stress and impact academic performance.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a mix of viewpoints regarding the importance of high school grades and the nature of physics as a discipline. There is no consensus on whether high school performance is indicative of future success, and opinions vary on the necessity of a strong work ethic for pursuing a career in physics.

Contextual Notes

Some statements reflect personal anecdotes and subjective experiences, which may not universally apply. The discussion includes varying perspectives on the relationship between high school performance and future academic success, as well as differing opinions on the nature of physics education.

Who May Find This Useful

High school students considering a future in physics, educators providing guidance to students, and individuals interested in the challenges of pursuing a STEM career.

um0123
Messages
151
Reaction score
0
im in high school and my grades are okay. I am no einstein, although i have read many books on relativity. I am just not doing well in school, because i get bored and don't do the work. if i do the work, i get good grades, but sometime i forget some equations. my GPA for first semester sophomore year was 3.0 and I am finishing my second semster in 7 weeks. if i got a 3.4, and tried really hard in junior and senior year, can i still become a particle physicist?

also, I am not so sure i want to be a particle physicist, I am only 15 and have only studied a little into physics. Hell, when i started sophomore year i wanted to do something with chemistry, then i read all this physics stuff, and i changed my mind to physics. i know i want to do physics, but what is each sub topic like?

P.S. what should i expect when going to college? i want to major in some form of physics, but am unsure which.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
um0123 said:
im in high school and my grades are okay. I am no einstein, although i have read many books on relativity. I am just not doing well in school, because i get bored and don't do the work. if i do the work, i get good grades, but sometime i forget some equations. my GPA for first semester sophomore year was 3.0 and I am finishing my second semster in 7 weeks. if i got a 3.4, and tried really hard in junior and senior year, can i still become a particle physicist?

also, I am not so sure i want to be a particle physicist, I am only 15 and have only studied a little into physics. Hell, when i started sophomore year i wanted to do something with chemistry, then i read all this physics stuff, and i changed my mind to physics. i know i want to do physics, but what is each sub topic like?

P.S. what should i expect when going to college? i want to major in some form of physics, but am unsure which.


Einstein didn't do well in school, so it sounds to me like you are an Einstein at school.
 
Kalzar89 said:
Einstein didn't do well in school, so it sounds to me like you are an Einstein at school.

Hate to burst your bubble but that's a myth. He was actually pretty good in school. Check out Isaacson's Einstein: his Life and Universe, he talks about that myth in Chapter 2.
 
Last edited:
DrummingAtom said:
Hate to burst your bubble but that's a myth. He was actually pretty good in school. Check out Isaacson's Einstein: his Life and Universe, he talks about that myth in Chapter 2.

My comment is based off an interview of Isaacson talking about his book, and telling how Einstein was slow at learning when he was young and was very rebellious. Plus, I was just joking around, no need to get so serious. I don't particularly like reading biography's though.
 
um0123 said:
im in high school and my grades are okay. I am no einstein, although i have read many books on relativity. I am just not doing well in school, because i get bored and don't do the work. if i do the work, i get good grades, but sometime i forget some equations. my GPA for first semester sophomore year was 3.0 and I am finishing my second semster in 7 weeks. if i got a 3.4, and tried really hard in junior and senior year, can i still become a particle physicist?

also, I am not so sure i want to be a particle physicist, I am only 15 and have only studied a little into physics. Hell, when i started sophomore year i wanted to do something with chemistry, then i read all this physics stuff, and i changed my mind to physics. i know i want to do physics, but what is each sub topic like?

P.S. what should i expect when going to college? i want to major in some form of physics, but am unsure which.

Highschool grades don't mean squat once you're accepted to a university, so as long as you get in somewhere, your chances aren't diminished to do something physics related.

Just don't close off doors for yourself. You're still young and I think it would be naive at this point to know what you want to do with the rest of your life. Certainly continue studying physics both academically and in your spare time, but don't allow it, at least at these early stages, to interfere with other plans.

The subtopics of physics are extremely varied and it would be too complicated to give a decent description of how they differ. What you can read in say a wikipedia article is about the level of intel I could give you.

Also, as an undergraduate you don't major in any form of physics. You major in physics. Guaranteed 90% of the classes you take will be general physics courses everyone else takes, and maybe you'll have a physics elective or two that will allow you to pick a subtopic and explore it in more detail but that's it. You don't really specialize unless you're doing research work junior/senior year, or until graduate school (long ways away for you).

Just have fun. Build up an enthusiasm, because a lot of that tends to dry up once you get into the rough and tumble of things (i.e black holes seem interesting until you get into the formalism of general relativity and wonder "Where the heck are the black holes?").
 
I think you need to ask yourself how badly you want to be a particle physicist. You will have to work very hard. If you're "bored and don't do the work", and you are too lazy to use proper capitalization and punctuation, you probably don't have the work ethic to succeed.

You can change, but you have to want to change.
 
Don't be fooled by some of the general physics books. While Physics is fascinating and exciting, it is TOUGH. Of course, if you really like the subject, then it is not a problem at all. I am not trying to say to not to study physics, just want you to know that more than often, physics is hard and, well, boring in some sense.
One more note, while particle physics is really interesting, don't limit yourself to this field. There are many exciting fields in physics, and more often, they are related to each others one way or the other. Expose yourself to all the topics (I think this is really the purpose of undergraduate level physics, and prepare you for more advance stuff).
 
Nabeshin said:
Highschool grades don't mean squat once you're accepted to a university, so as long as you get in somewhere, your chances aren't diminished to do something physics related.

They mean squat: they showcase ability at a young age, which is very important. Sure, no body will hound you about them once your in, but more often then not they will reflect your future performance.

Kalzar89 said:
My comment is based off an interview of Isaacson talking about his book, and telling how Einstein was slow at learning when he was young and was very rebellious. Plus, I was just joking around, no need to get so serious. I don't particularly like reading biography's though.

Einstein was the top of his class from an early age. He was so ahead in math, that his parents had to supplement him with books. He mastered geometry and began calculus at around age 13. He had speech difficulties early on, but that didn't hinder his performance in school at all.
 
If it's any encouragement at all, I was in the same boat you're in now. I had my first encounter with Physics through reading about relativity. I was bored in high school, and consequently wasn't focused. I had a GPA of around 3.2 . My junior year I hear about an early acceptance program at the University of Iowa, and ended up doing it. Now I'm near the top of my class double majoring in Physics and Math, and am involved with a few different research projects.

I guess the point of that is that don't let go of something you want just because you don't think your high school grades are high enough. If you truly want to do something, then go do it.
 
  • #10
thanks for the information and encouragement. people keep telling me that its so important to get into a highly prestigous undergrad college and its a lot of pressure, which makes me even worse at school, because its so stressful.
 
  • #11
You don't know stress until you've been in college.
 
  • #12
Howers said:
You don't know stress until you've been in college.

youre probably right, but still, you can understand where I am coming from
 
  • #13
Howers said:
You don't know stress until you've been in college.

It's just community college, but college is far less stressful to me than high school.

In college, you don't need to worry about somebody spitting gum in your hair, pushing you down a flight of steps, stealing your books, et cetera.

I finished high school with like a 1.5 GPA, and right now, I'm crushing community college classes. I'm the only A in my physics 1 class, I've got a high B in Calc 2 (hoping to pull it up to an A by the end), et cetera.

Taking 14 credits and working 40 hours a week, plus a mortgage to pay... and it's still less stressful than high school.
 
  • #14
Howers said:
You don't know stress until you've been in college.

You also don't know fun!
 
  • #15
It's natural at your age to be chopping and changing the ideas of what you want to do with the rest of your working life (actually, yours hasn't even started yet!) so don't panic. Most people change careers several times, so the best advice for someone such as yourself may be to pursue the things that you feel you're interested in. Try your hardest to get the best results, if you're struggling with keeping up in workload - then maybe arrange to study with someone, form a study group or a study-plan and find a partner to work along with you.

University is a whole other world, when you're introduced to physics at increasingly more detailed levels you'll find that most of the subjects you know about just now aren't what you thought they were- and it's likely that ultimate goals will change. It's a good idea to have long term aims, but since you haven't yet started on the long-term path (i.e. University) focus on the short.
 
  • #16
I think you will be able to become a particle physicist (granted you can find work after the 10yrs at school that is)

I myself dropped out of college twice (In the UK, so this will be more of a ref to the UK school system but it can be applied to the US system) because i hated it and just got so bored. then took a year out got some money together and went back and just got through it with reasonable grades.

When i got to undergrad(3yrs) it all changed as i was able to focus on the areas i loved.
Then after that did my Masters(2yrs) and PhD(6yrs) which were bliss as i got to just focus all my attention on what i enjoyed.
Where as back in school/college(School would put me at around 15 so this links to where you most likly are in the US system) i had to learn just stuff i didn't really care about.. i would just say grind through and when you find what you enjoy it will seem so much better.

...
Just a side note.. i now study Quark-gluon plasma at the LHC for CREN and work with many Particle physicists and and they seem to have a right old laugh.. so is worth sticking with it.

Hope this kinda helps.

~N~
 

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
3K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 32 ·
2
Replies
32
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 33 ·
2
Replies
33
Views
6K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
2K