Is Homeopathic Dog Pain Medicine Effective or Just a Placebo?

  • Thread starter Thread starter FlexGunship
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Medicine Pain
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the effectiveness of homeopathic dog pain medicine, specifically a homeopathic spray. Participants assert that such remedies primarily serve to comfort the pet owner rather than provide any real relief to the dog, suggesting that the perceived benefits are largely a result of the placebo effect. The conversation raises questions about the mechanisms behind homeopathy and whether it can genuinely alleviate pain in animals, given their lack of understanding of medicinal concepts. The consensus highlights concerns over the potential neglect of proper veterinary care due to reliance on these remedies.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of homeopathy principles
  • Knowledge of placebo effect mechanisms
  • Familiarity with veterinary pain management
  • Awareness of pet owner psychology
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the efficacy of homeopathic treatments in veterinary medicine
  • Explore scientific studies on the placebo effect in animals
  • Investigate alternative pain management options for dogs
  • Learn about regulations surrounding homeopathic products for pets
USEFUL FOR

Pet owners, veterinarians, animal health professionals, and anyone interested in the implications of homeopathic treatments for animal care.

FlexGunship
Gold Member
Messages
425
Reaction score
9
419ENG00Q2L._SL500_AA300_.jpg
(Source: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000FOX4QI/?tag=pfamazon01-20)

I saw this on TV a few years ago (back when I had cable). It's a homeopathic dog pain spray. Yes, that's right. It's a homeopathic spray for your dog.

That means, that AT BEST, it provides comfort to the dog's owner by allowing them to falsely believe their dog isn't in pain anymore. You haven't done anything to help your dog with his or her discomfort, but you feel less guilty about it! This is a real thing... or used to be.

So is this a case of "vicarious" placebo effect? What possible mechanism could make the dog feel better when it's ill-equipped to even understand the concept of medicine. Doesn't the placebo-effect rely, fundamentally, on having a vague understanding of the concept of healing?

Oooooor... maybe this is finally the proof that homeopaths need that homeopathy works by a mechanism other than the placebo effect.
As a side note, my great uncle died from an overdose of his homeopathic medicine... he forgot to take it!

[URL]http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/4/46928/1413875-badum_tish_super.jpg[/URL]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Biology news on Phys.org
Due to the extreme popularity of this thread, I think it should be made a sticky. Mods?
 
I always get a kick out of reading the "No side effects" on homeopathic remedies. In order to have a "side effect," something must first have an effect!

Regarding the spray; it actually really pisses me off. People's pets won't be properly treated and will still be in pain.