MHB How can I maximize my points when rolling multiple dice with different options?

  • Thread starter Thread starter zweilinkehaende
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Complex Dice
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around maximizing points when rolling dice, where scoring occurs by rolling a 5 or 6. Two strategies are presented: adding additional dice to reroll 6s or rerolling non-scoring dice (1-4). The calculations reveal that the expected scores for each strategy depend on the values of x (initial dice) and y (additional dice). The first strategy can theoretically yield infinite points, while the second provides a more stable average score. The main challenge is determining the optimal strategy based on specific values of x and y.
zweilinkehaende
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Hi,

i was wondering how to calculate this problem:

Rolling a 5 or a 6 on a dice means you score a point. You are given x dices. You have 2 options: Either you add y dices to your dicepool and can roll dices that show a 6 again (still gaining a point) or you can reroll your dices not showing a 5 or 6.
At which values of y and x should i choose which method to gain the most points (on average).

I made multiple attempts but always failed because i could in theory score infinite points using the first method.

I hope i chose the right subforum.

Ty for your help.

PS.: Please excuse my poor english, it's not my first language.
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
zweilinkehaende said:
Hi,

i was wondering how to calculate this problem:

Rolling a 5 or a 6 on a dice means you score a point. You are given x dices. You have 2 options: Either you add y dices to your dicepool and can roll dices that show a 6 again (still gaining a point) or you can reroll your dices not showing a 5 or 6.
At which values of y and x should i choose which method to gain the most points (on average).

I made multiple attempts but always failed because i could in theory score infinite points using the first method.

I hope i chose the right subforum.

Ty for your help.

PS.: Please excuse my poor english, it's not my first language.

Hi zweilinkehaende! Welcome to MHB! :)

If you can only score points and not lose them, adding an infinite number of dice will indeed gain you an infinite number of points.

Is there perhaps a condition that you lose points?
Perhaps you lose a point if you roll 1-4?
 
zweilinkehaende,

I am not sure I understand the rules. Here is what I think you are saying. Please let us know if this is correct or not.

Positive integers $x$ and $y$ are fixed in advance. You have two options:

1. Roll $x$ dice, then re-roll any that do not come up 5 or 6. Your score is the total numbers of 5s and 6s.
OR
2. Roll $x+y$ dice, then re-roll any that come up 6. Your score is the total numbers of 5s and 6s, including the dice that came up 6 on the first roll.

Is this a correct interpretation?

If so, in the first option the expected number of 5s or 6s on the first role is $ (2/6) x$. The expected number of 5s or 6s on the second role is $(2/6) (x - (2/6)x) = (8/36) x$. So the expected total score is $(2/6) x + (8/36)x = (5/9) x$.

In the second option, the expected number of 5s on the first role is $(1/6) (x+y)$, and the expected number of 6s is also $(1/6)(x+y)$. The expected number of 5s or 6s on the second role is $(2/6)(1/6)(x+y)$. So the expected total score is $((2)(1/6)(x+y) + (2/6)(1/6)(x+y) = (7/18)(x+y)$.
 
I like Serena said:
Hi zweilinkehaende! Welcome to MHB! :)

If you can only score points and not lose them, adding an infinite number of dice will indeed gain you an infinite number of points.

Is there perhaps a condition that you lose points?
Perhaps you lose a point if you roll 1-4?

No there is no condition under which points are lost. I'm searching for the optimal strategy depending on the x and y values. For example if x is 60 and y is 1:
Strategy 1 (adding y and rerolling 6s) would give me approximatly 24 on average. (61*1/3 + 2/6*1/6*61 + 2/6*1/6*1/6*61+...)
Strategy 2 (rerolling 1-4s) would give me approximatly 33 (60*1/3+(60-(60*1/3))*1/3= 33.33).

Obviously i would choose Strategy 2 in this case. But how do i calculate when to switch strategies? (with x and y values reversed it would be quite obvious)

The player doesn't get to choose the x or y values, only strategies.
 
awkward said:
zweilinkehaende,

I am not sure I understand the rules. Here is what I think you are saying. Please let us know if this is correct or not.

Positive integers $x$ and $y$ are fixed in advance. You have two options:

1. Roll $x$ dice, then re-roll any that do not come up 5 or 6. Your score is the total numbers of 5s and 6s.
OR
2. Roll $x+y$ dice, then re-roll any that come up 6. Your score is the total numbers of 5s and 6s, including the dice that came up 6 on the first roll.

Is this a correct interpretation?

If so, in the first option the expected number of 5s or 6s on the first role is $ (2/6) x$. The expected number of 5s or 6s on the second role is $(2/6) (x - (2/6)x) = (8/36) x$. So the expected total score is $(2/6) x + (8/36)x = (5/9) x$.

In the second option, the expected number of 5s on the first role is $(1/6) (x+y)$, and the expected number of 6s is also $(1/6)(x+y)$. The expected number of 5s or 6s on the second role is $(2/6)(1/6)(x+y)$. So the expected total score is $((2)(1/6)(x+y) + (2/6)(1/6)(x+y) = (7/18)(x+y)$.

The first one is correct, but the second one can be infinetly continued. The 6s on the second role can be reroled again. And the 6s that come up again, and again... .

My main problem is that i don't know how to express 2/6*(x+y) + 2/6*1/6*(x+y) + 2/6*1/6*1/6*(x+y) + ... correctly.
 
zweilinkehaende said:
The first one is correct, but the second one can be infinetly continued. The 6s on the second role can be reroled again. And the 6s that come up again, and again... .

My main problem is that i don't know how to express 2/6*(x+y) + 2/6*1/6*(x+y) + 2/6*1/6*1/6*(x+y) + ... correctly.

It seems to me that you're only supposed to reroll once...
Anyway, what you have there is a so called geometric series.
In general we have:
$$a + ar + ar^2 + ... = \frac{a}{1-r}$$
So:
$$\frac 26 \cdot (x+y) + \frac 26\cdot \frac 16\cdot (x+y) + \frac 26\cdot \frac 16\cdot \frac 16\cdot (x+y) + ...
= \frac{\frac 26\cdot(x+y)}{1-\frac 16} = \frac 25 (x+y)$$
 
Seemingly by some mathematical coincidence, a hexagon of sides 2,2,7,7, 11, and 11 can be inscribed in a circle of radius 7. The other day I saw a math problem on line, which they said came from a Polish Olympiad, where you compute the length x of the 3rd side which is the same as the radius, so that the sides of length 2,x, and 11 are inscribed on the arc of a semi-circle. The law of cosines applied twice gives the answer for x of exactly 7, but the arithmetic is so complex that the...
Is it possible to arrange six pencils such that each one touches the other five? If so, how? This is an adaption of a Martin Gardner puzzle only I changed it from cigarettes to pencils and left out the clues because PF folks don’t need clues. From the book “My Best Mathematical and Logic Puzzles”. Dover, 1994.
Back
Top